argument top image

Should after-school detention be banned? Show more Show less
Back to question

School detention is a divisive topic in the learning community, as educators disagree on the effectiveness of school-based disciplinary actions. Some believe it is a more effective use of time for students who tend to misbehave, while others believe this puts educators in an excessively disciplinary role rather than focusing on teaching their students content during the school day.

No, after-school detention should not be banned Show more Show less

School detention is one of the only tactics teachers have as a disciplinary method, and it acts as an important time occupant for kids who may otherwise misuse their free time. It supplements education and prevents misbehavior, making it an effective punishment.
(1 of 2) Next position >

After-school detention simultaneously disciplines and keeps troubled kids occupied

School detention is intended first and foremost as a disciplinary strategy, but it also helps teachers understand their students better and keep troubled kids under a watchful eye, preventing them from misusing their time.

The Argument

Detention is not a simple blanket punishment used to admonish troubled kids. It is at once a reprimand for their wrongdoings and a prevention tactic for further misbehavior.[1] Teachers have limited tools at hand to control their students' behavior, and detention is one of the few that can take place within the school setting and also be productive towards furthering a student’s education.[2] Detention can come in many forms, and so long as a teacher is using appropriate and effective methods of disciplining a student, it should be retained as a form of educational reprimand.[3] The additional benefit of after-school detention is that it keeps that subset of children who are likely to get up to trouble outside of school as well in a setting where they can have a watchful eye on them. This time is not meant to be cruel but disciplinary, and it offers an opportunity for students to bond with teachers and make up for work they may have missed while misbehaving.

Counter arguments

The teacher should not be a disciplinarian. If the concern is keeping the student occupied during all hours of the day to prevent them from causing too much trouble, they should contact the parents to take over that disciplinarian role.[4]

Proponents

Premises

Rejecting the premises

References

  1. https://www.scmp.com/yp/discover/your-voice/opinion/article/3060164/face-detention-effective-punishment-students
  2. https://richardjamesrogers.com/2018/05/13/the-effective-use-of-detentions/
  3. https://www.apa.org/pubs/info/reports/zero-tolerance-report.pdf
  4. https://www.forbes.com/sites/nickmorrison/2014/08/31/the-surprising-truth-about-discipline-in-schools/?sh=74a9dc863f83
This page was last edited on Thursday, 12 Nov 2020 at 19:51 UTC