argument top image

< Back to question Is there too much money in football? Show more Show less

From humble beginnings, football has exploded into one of the most-watched sports in the world. Far from being just a game, football is now a multi-billion dollar industry. But does compromise the integrity of the game? Would football be better if there was less money involved?

Yes, there's too much money in football Show more Show less

The influence of money has ruined the spirit of football and the game would be better off it could go back to being less focused on money.
(1 of 2) Next position >

Commercialisation and advertising has taken over the game of football

Corporate logos are everywhere in football, while sponsors often get a large amount of tickets for the biggest matches. Football should not be an advertisement for products.
< (3 of 4) Next argument >

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more before voting ↓

Proponents


The Argument

A person watches a football game for... well, the football. They tune in to the TV or drive up to the stadium for the sport, for their favorite club or team; not for commercials. Unfortunately, fans today gets the reverse treatment. Expecting to enjoy a game of soccer, they instead get bombarded with brand names and logo in a way that takes away from their enjoyment of the game. Advertising is everywhere in football. Just look at the uniforms of the players; they're either covered in multiple company logos, or dominated by one large one. One can hardly even tell what club the player represents, but one can certainly tell who's paying them.[1] And the problem is only growing. In the United States, Major League Soccer is allowing teams to add one more sponsor logo to their uniforms; by removing the MLS logo from the sleeves.[2] The logo of the league itself is being replaced by another ad. Nothing could be better representative of the ad problem in football than that. As if that wasn't enough, company sponsors also have control over ticket sales. For example, during the Women's FIFA World Cup 2019, Visa customers had first access to match tickets.[3] Sponsoring the league or the tournament is one thing, but taking tickets away from dedicated fans who happen to not use Visa is somewhat absurd. It really feels as though this sponsorship deal is shoving Visa down people's throats. Fans can't enjoy the sport anymore without kowtowing to brands, just as the leagues themselves do. All this commercialization goes to show that football is no longer focused on the sport itself, or competition, or even team spirit. The name of the game today is money. The club needs money; the league needs money; even the players want money. And it's natural to want to get paid. But the way they beat people over the head with these advertisements, it feels as though making money is all that matters.

Counter arguments

This argument seems a bit nitpicky. Not every uniform is gaudily covered in company logos; many just don't look that bad. And at any rate, it doesn't affect actual play. Does a spectacular goal by Messi or Ronaldo really diminish just because they've got an extra picture on their shirt? Only the most traditionalist, stick-in-the-mud fan would think that. Football actually handles its advertising quite well. In football, the ads are little logos on shirts that one can barely even see on TV or from the stands. Meanwhile, baseball plasters its ads all over the back wall; with every pop-up or change of ends, the viewer is bombarded with billboard-sized messes. Basketball and American football have a commercial break seemingly every few seconds. By contrast, football's ads seem to be handled the best out of any sport.

Premises

Rejecting the premises


References

  1. https://sites.duke.edu/wcwp/2015/02/17/how-many-advertisements-is-enough/
  2. https://www.chicagotribune.com/sports/soccer/ct-spt-mls-jerseys-advertisements-20181024-story.html
  3. https://usa.visa.com/about-visa/sponsorships-promotions/fifa-partnership.html

This page was last edited on Tuesday, 22 Sep 2020 at 07:23 UTC

Explore related arguments