Mapping the world's opinions

argument top image

< Back to question Are there more than two genders? Show more Show less

Whether binary or a spectrum, innate or a construct, or soon to be irrelevant, gender is one of the most divisive questions on the world's lips. Are there more than two genders? What are the sides to the gender debate?

No, there are only two genders Show more Show less

While it can be socially influenced, gender has been shown to be biologically compelled. Even when raised the opposite sex, an individual will still find the urge to behave in line with their born gender. Transition surgeries and therapies are meant to bridge gender incongruity, but result in higher suicidality.
< (2 of 4) Next position >

Gender correlates with sex, and there are only two sexes

There are only two genders because there are only two sexes. Special cases, such as intersex people, are a rare exception to the biological male and female sexes. The existence of rare exceptions does not invalidate there generally being only two sexes.
< (2 of 4) Next argument >

The Argument

Outside of English, many languages only have one word that means both gender and sex. Gender and sex are the same thing for many cultures. Thus, gender and sex are synonymous. There are only two sexes: XX and XY. People with XX chromosomes produce eggs and people with XY chromosomes produce sperm. There cannot be a third gender because there are only two chromosome configurations that people can have. If you are born with XX chromosomes, you are a female in sex and in gender, whereas if you are born with XY chromosomes, you are a male. Intersex people, who do not have the standard genital configuration that correlates with their chromosomes, do exist, but they are rare exceptions. Just because there are rare medical exceptions does not mean that there are more than two genders. For instance, just because some people are born with more than ten fingers does not mean that we would say, "Humans can have ten or more fingers." Rare exceptions do not mean that a rule is false. Additionally, in every other mammalian species, we have no notion of gender that is different from sex. Dogs and cats are male and female based on their biological reproductive organs. There is no scientific reason to identify sex differently in humans.[1]

Counter arguments

Sex is much more complicated than XX equaling female and XY equaling male. There are many people who are born with genitals that do not "match" their chromosomes, and they are not a rare exception. These people are intersex. Researchers estimate that as many as 1 in 100 people are intersex, so the condition is certainly not rare. Intersex people may not even realize that they are intersex; for instance, XX individuals may develop testes due to containing a fragment of the Y chromosome, but their XX dominance may make their external genitals and secondary sex characteristics appear entirely "female." Many people do not realize they are intersex until they seek help for infertility issues or other invasive medical procedures. In an operation on a hernia, one man, who was 70 years old and who had fathered four children, was found to have a womb.[2] Additionally, with the help of new technologies in DNA sequencing and cell biology, researchers are finding that almost everyone, to varying degrees, contains some cells that are sexed differently than the rest of their body. The assumption that all of a person's cells contain the same exact set of genes is false. So, even someone who has a penis and testes and mostly XY chromosomes may contain some cells with XX chromosomes.[2] Biologists are continually finding new evidence for the claim that sex is a spectrum that is mistakenly oversimplified into a binary. There is no reason to think that there are only two genders based on sex because there are actually more than two sexes.

Premises

Rejecting the premises


References

  1. https://www.heritage.org/gender/commentary/transgender-ideology-riddled-contradictions-here-are-the-big-ones
  2. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/sex-redefined-the-idea-of-2-sexes-is-overly-simplistic1/

This page was last edited on Monday, 20 Jul 2020 at 23:35 UTC

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more before voting ↑

Explore related arguments