argument top image

Has the Good Friday Agreement been a success? Show more Show less
Back to question

The Good Friday Agreement is a set of agreements, concluded on April 10th 1998 and ratified by popular vote on May 22nd 1998, that secured the devolved government in Northern Ireland. The agreement was the result of a long period of political uncertainty and extreme violence in Northern Ireland, known as ‘The Troubles’, which was a period of conflict that ran from the 1960s to, generally agreed, the Good Friday Agreement.

The Good Friday Agreement has been a failure Show more Show less

The Good Friday Agreement has been a failure due to the fact that Northern Ireland has seen a polarisation in politics since 1998. Many of the terms of the treaty, such as the release of prisoners, has also been hotly contested.
< (2 of 2)

The Good Friday Agreement has led to a polarisation in politics

The Good Friday Agreement did not lead to a more united political sphere. In contrast, more extreme parties such as the DUP and Sinn Fein have become even more popular.
< (2 of 2)

Context

The Good Friday Agreement (GFA), agreed on April 10th1998 and ratified by popular vote on May 22nd 1998, was an agreement that brought about the end of a period of violent conflict in Northern Ireland known as 'The Troubles'. The Troubles refers to decades of violence where Nationalists (usually Catholic) were locked into bitter and deadly dispute with Unionists (usually Protestant) in Northern Ireland. The GFA established a new government that would be a power share between the Unionists and the Nationalists, therefore helping to establish a tentative peace. Although the sustained violence may be at an end, Northern Ireland's political landscape remains as polarised as ever.

The Argument

When the Good Friday Agreement (GFA) was signed in 1998, many heralded it as the start of a new future for the troubled region of Northern Ireland. After decades of sectarian conflict known as 'The Troubles', the GFA was meant to mark a new turning point in relations between the Nationalists (predominantly Catholics) and the Unionists (predominantly Protestant). However, while the violence has undeniably died down, the GFA has not brought about the political unity that so many believed would come. Quite the opposite, politics in Northern Ireland is now arguably more divided than ever, with extremist parties at both ends of the political spectrum garnering increasing support. Two key figures in the Northern Ireland Peace Process, John Hume and David Trimble, came from Irish Catholic Nationalist and Irish Protestant Unionist backgrounds respectively. The two parties that they led, John Hume and the Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP) and David Trimble and the Ulster Unionist Party (UUP), were viewed as moderate political parties, despite occupying differing ends on the political spectrum. Since the GFA, however, these parties have not enjoyed as much success as the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) and Sinn Fein, two parties which sit on the more extreme end of the SDLP and UUP. There has, in other words, been a notable shift to the more extreme end of both sides. This political shift in the Northern Irish political landscape has been commented upon by Oxford Political scientist Geoffrey Evans who has remarked on how, 'the DUP and united Ireland supporters Sinn Fein managed to replace the more centrists parties in Northern Ireland after taking a more hardline approach to the Good Friday Agreement negotiations.'[1] This view is also shared by some citizens of Northern Ireland, as one lamented on the 20th anniversary of the GFA, 'far from bringing the perceived “both sides” closer together, the result of the Belfast Agreement has been to polarise the nationalist and unionist communities and to increase in popularity the more extreme parties'[2] The Good Friday Agreement has therefore not been the political success that so many believed it would be back in 1998. Far from encouraging a more centrist, united political landscape, twenty years later the electorate and political parties remain more divided than ever. Perhaps more worryingly, voters have eschewed the more moderate SDLP and UUP, so instrumental in forging the GFA, and have instead turned to the more hardline Sinn Fein and DUP.

Counter arguments

Proponents

Premises

[P1] Before the Good Friday Agreement, the Social Democratic and Labour Party and the Ulster Unionist Parties were prominent forces in Northern Irish politics. [P2] The Social Democratic and Labour Party was more nationalist while the Ulster Unionist Party was Unionist. [P3] After the Good Friday Agreement, the two parties that dominated Northern Irish politics were Sinn Fein (nationalist) and the Democratic Unionist Party (unionist). [P4] Sinn Fein and the Democratic Unionist Party are both considered more extreme in their respective opinions than the SDLP and the UUP. [P5] Therefore the Good Friday Agreement has not been a success as it has led to extreme polarisation in politics.

Rejecting the premises

References

  1. https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/northern-ireland/northern-irelands-polarised-style-of-politics-has-spilled-over-into-rest-of-uk-experts-38574960.html
  2. https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/good-friday-agreement/poll-was-the-good-friday-agreement-a-success-or-failure-36793003.html
This page was last edited on Monday, 24 Aug 2020 at 19:51 UTC

Explore related arguments