argument top image

Do we have a soul? Show more Show less
Back to question

The soul as a concept is widely debated and has an array of definitions. It is broadly defined as the essence of our being, that which makes one who they are. It is normally considered beyond the physical world, and often eternal or immortal. For generations, humans have sought to explain the soul through religion, philosophy, and science, and there are countless theories and controversies regarding this question. Do we have a soul?

Religious ideas have discussed the soul for centuries Show more Show less

Religion, the long-lasting human tradition of explaining the world around us, has lots to say about the essence of our being.
< (3 of 3)

Judaism holds mixed messages on the soul

One of humanity's oldest religions has changed its perception of the soul over time.

The Argument

Historically, Judaism preached of a soul that was inseparable from the physical body. The soul was the thoughts emotions, and life-force of the body, but it did not and could not exist separately. Although it was not a physical organ, it acted as a part of the body and could not continue on after death. This idea of the soul was based on what was directly stated in the Torah, the Jewish equivalent of the bible. Over time, as ancient Greek philosophy on the soul and Christian and Muslim ideas made their way into Jewish scholarly discussions, many Jewish thinkers began embracing the idea of dualism, the soul and physical body existing separately. In these conceptualizations, the soul exists more apart from the body and is more connected to the divine and spiritual planes. In addition, it can exist after the body dies and ceases to exist. Today, there are many sects of Judaism that embrace both ideas of the soul.[1]

Counter arguments

Only the original idea of the soul should be counted a Judaism. The dualism ideas of later years where influences from other philosophies, so they don't truly represent the Jewish idea of a soul. At its core, the soul is tied to the body and exists in the same subsequent plane.

Proponents

Premises

[P1] The Torah characterizes the soul as reliant upon the body, and not continuing after death. [P2] As Jewish thinkers began to draw influences from other philosophies, the idea of a separate body and soul was embraced more widely.

Rejecting the premises

References

  1. https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/jewish-spirituality-and-the-soul/

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more ↑

Discuss

This page was last edited on Saturday, 15 Aug 2020 at 01:47 UTC

Explore related arguments