argument top image

< Back to question Is Marvel or DC better? Show more Show less

With both making profits in the billions of dollars, the Marvel and DC franchises are juggernauts. Both have existed for nearly a century, and have spanned comic books and movies as well as every piece of merchandise imaginable. Every fan has their own opinion of which is superior, so which is it?

Marvel is better Show more Show less

Worth more money, Marvel is the most successful movie franchise of all time.
(1 of 2) Next position >

The characters and storylines of the Marvel universe are more entertaining.

Marvel storylines have much more levity to them than DC, making them more enjoyable to watch or read. Dark, challenging stories can be a turn-off to those who just want a lighthearted escape for a while.
(1 of 3) Next argument >

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more before voting ↓

Proponents


The Argument

Marvel knows how to draw in its audience with its bright tone and effective use of humor. This element of their presentation is why their comics, and particularly their movies, have seen such success. They know how to entertain both the average viewer as well as the hardcore fan. Fan-favorite Spider-Man, with his youthful exuberance and humorous persona, is known in both the comics and the movies for his lighthearted heroism and humorous exploits. As a teenage student by day and vigilante by night, the hero's dangerous crime-fighting life clashes with his more mundane, but almost no less critical, responsibilities of Peter Parker - like family, school, and his job - making for some very entertaining interactions. And while fighting crime, Spider-Man often takes time to taunt and mock his opponents in humorous ways, before truly making a fool out of them by webbing them up and leaving them to the police. Another fan-favorite takes levity to its utmost extreme, that character being Deadpool. Deadpool is known for his vicious mockery of friend and foe alike, and making a joke out of even the most grim situation. His almost immortal nature allows him to make intensely gory humor into yet another bit. And his tendency to break the fourth wall is a time-honored comic tradition that, while certainly amusing, keeps a fan grounded without breaking immersion too much. DC's reputation of grimdark stories can turn a prospective fan off. It's a much better method to draw someone in with grounded, relatable humor and levity, before getting them hooked on the story.

Counter arguments

DC has plenty of lighthearted stories as well. Just look at the Teen Titans comics and animated series, and also Teen Titans Go!. Like Spider-Man, they show young heroes balancing teenage life with superhero work. Or look at the Harley Quinn animated series, which portrays a humorous, satirical take on the heroes and villains of Gotham. But aside from that, levity isn't always a good thing. If you focus too much on entertainment value, you lose out on exploring a deeper storyline with a meaningful plot and themes. Summer blockbusters are a fun watch, but they're ultimately meaningless. The Marvel movies have been criticized for generic plots, overdone comedy, and shallow action.

Premises

Rejecting the premises


References


    This page was last edited on Monday, 22 Jun 2020 at 17:40 UTC

    Explore related arguments