Mapping the world's opinions

argument top image

What are the themes in Of Mice and Men? Show more Show less

John Steinbeck's timeless novel, Of Mice and Men, is a piece of literature that many teens encounter in high school. It explores the story of two migrant workers during the Great Depression. What are the central themes of the novel?

Of Mice and Men is about prejudice Show more Show less

George remarks that he used to play mean-spirited pranks on Lennie. Also, Crooks (an African-American man on the ranch with them) is often the target of racism and isolation.
< Previous (4 of 5 Positions) Next >

Mistreatment of Lennie

Throughout the novel, George often makes passive-aggressive (and sometimes, just plain rude) comments to Lennie.
< Previous (1 of 2 Arguments) Next >

Context

The Argument

While George is Lennie's best friend, he still mistreats him a lot. George often speaks to Lennie about how much easier (and better) his life would be if he didn't have to take care of him. He also admits to playing hurtful pranks on Lennie in the past, which would often cause Lennie to be injured (or for him to do something ridiculous). George also belittles Lennie by expressing his relief that they're not related. George doesn't understand Lennie's disability fully, which is why he falls into the pattern of mocking and belittling Lennie. This also shows that other characters define Lennie as a product of his disability. This promotes a culture of misunderstanding. Some view Lennie as a child-like, harmless man, while others view him as a dangerous and unintelligent man. These two views (and the ways in which those on the farm don't seek to fully understand him) leads to his isolation and eventual murder of Curley's wife.

Counter arguments

Framing

Premises

[P1] Lennie is often mistreated by others (specifically George) for his disability. [P2] Due to the way in which George and others treat him, Lennie is not able to be fully understood by others. [P3] Since Lennie is not understood by those around him, he stays isolated from others. [P4] Lennie's isolation causes him to be in an environment where he was able to kill the puppy without anyone noticing (which then leads to him accidentally killing Curley's wife).

Rejecting the premises

Proponents

Further Reading

References

    Explore related arguments

    This page was last edited on Wednesday, 13 May 2020 at 04:40 UTC