argument top image

Who is the greatest tennis player of all time? Show more Show less
Back to question

Tennis is a truly international sport, with great players from many different nations competing at tournaments across the globe to determine the best. The sport's preponderance of prestigious championships has allowed many different players to compile glittering records of achievements. But what matters most - major titles, peak form, contemporaneous competition, or something else entirely? And in consideration of it all, which player stands above the rest as the greatest to ever pick up a racquet?

Rafael Nadal Show more Show less

The King of Clay dominated the French Open like never before, and won pretty much everything else too.
< (2 of 5) Next position >

Nadal had the toughest opposition

Rafael Nadal had to contend with the prime years of both Roger Federer and Novak Djokovic.
Novak Djokovic Rafael Nadal Roger Federer
< (2 of 2) Next argument >

The Argument

From the emergence of Roger Federer as the world's best tennis player in 2004 up to the early 2020s, men's tennis has been dominated largely by the "Big Three" players: Federer, Rafael Nadal, and Novak Djokovic. While each of the three has had unprecedented success and has had to contend with the other two on numerous occasions, Nadal has faced a relatively steeper challenge from the Big Three era than either of his rivals have. Federer, as the oldest of the three and first to achieve breakout success, was able to accumulate a large portion of his Grand Slam titles in a relatively weaker era of competition. Federer won 12 Grand Slam championships from 2003-2007, dominating less accomplished players while Nadal and Djokovic were still developing. Djokovic, as the youngest and last to come into his prime years, similarly benefited later in the Big Three era. Thus Nadal, in between the ages of Federer and Djokovic, had his athletic prime years overlap on either end with the prime years of either Federer, or Djokovic, or both. This forced Nadal to win his biggest championships under the most difficult possible circumstances: in direct competition with not one but two other legitimate candidates to be considered the best player of all time. Yet in spite of this fierce competition, Nadal succeeded, and compiled a list of victories comparable to those of his rivals and any other player in history.

Counter arguments

Nadal came to prominence after Federer, but before Djokovic reached his prime. Nadal won 3 of his 19 grand slams before Novak won his first, and 9 of his 19 before Djokovic's dominant period began in 2011. Djokovic had the most challenging entry into top-level tennis competition, facing Federer and Nadal in their prime.

Premises

Rejecting the premises

References

This page was last edited on Friday, 18 Sep 2020 at 08:27 UTC

Explore related arguments