Mapping the world's opinions

argument top image

Is coronavirus aggravating Islamophobia in India? Show more Show less

As covid-19 hit the headlines and became a national emergency in India, Islamophobia surged. On Twitter, furious posts poured out of the nation with the gruesome hashtag #CoronavirusJihad. The inference was clear: many Indians were using the pandemic as an excuse to victimise its Muslim population. Critics claim its government has done little to stop this, while others say the threat is exaggerated.

No, coronavirus is easing religious tensions Show more Show less

The shared fight against the disease is uniting religious communities.
(1 of 3 Positions) Next >

The nation stands as one

Shows of solidarity are growing as the country comes together to beat the virus.
(1 of 1 Argument) Next >
BJP Hinduism Islam coronavirus ethics health politics religion

Context

On 5 April 2020, India switched off its lights. Prime Minister Modi had called for a symbolic stand against the virus, requesting all 1.3 billion citizens to turn off their electricity for 9 minutes, lighting candles to represent their shared spiritual fight. The move was seen as part of a national drive to push "togetherness" during the crisis, and join divided communities across ideological lines.

The Argument

The pandemic has given rise to solidarity. Facing a shared enemy together, religious groups are no longer finger pointing at each other. They have a new threat to worry about, and working together is vital to overcoming it. From the top, government initiatives - such as the candlelit vigil - to bring a sense of shared purpose to its citizens, seems to be working. As Krishna Nandkeolyar writes in Gulf New,"India overwhelmingly responded to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's call on Sunday night. Right at 9 p.m., Indians switched off its lights and lit candles or flashed mobile torches for nine minutes to express solidarity with "Corona warriors."[1]

Counter arguments

The vigil was more symbolic of how divided the nation is. Its fractured society, and growing tensions, have made moves such as this more urgent than ever before. Yet, such moves can only serve as a window dressing. They fail to deal with the real problem at hand, shown just last month in rising sectarian violence in India.

Framing

Premises

Rejecting the premises

Proponents

Further Reading

References

  1. https://gulfnews.com/photos/news/covid-19-india-lights-candles-in-a-show-of-solidarity-against-coronavirus-1.1586105797656?slide=2
This page was last edited on Monday, 6 Apr 2020 at 11:41 UTC