Mapping the world's opinions

argument top image

< Back to question Did nationalism predate nation states? Show more Show less

Today, we are used to both the nation-state and the idea of nationalism. However, it may be possible to have one without the other. Authors have written about nationalism for centuries, but the nation state as we know it has existed a relatively short amount of time. So, did nationalism predate the nation?

Yes, nationalism predated nation states. Show more Show less

There is strong evidence of behaviors akin to nationalism in societies that predate our modern idea of the "nation state."
(1 of 3) Next position >

Nationalism is a form of tribalism

Tribalism: the behaviour and attitudes that stem from strong loyalty to one's own tribe or social group
(1 of 3) Next argument >

Context

Tribalism has existed for millennia and can be traced back through history as existing before what we would consider a nation state or even a proto-nation state.

The Argument

A nation can be defined as a body of people united by common descent and culture, often inhabiting one specific area. Loyalty to this body or group is often seen as inherent: people like to be with others who have the same religion, language and cultural practices, leading them to seek to live together, thus forming the nation state out of nationalism. In prehistoric societies this led to conflicts between different nations who believed that their practices were superior, indicating that nation states were formed to resolve these conflicts so people could live within their own national group. Additionally, the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy suggests that modern nationalism is particularly prominent amongst groups who do not yet have their own state, such as Palestinians and Kurds, indicating that nationalism must predate the formation of a nation state because otherwise, nation states would not develop. [1]

Counter arguments

What creates these loyalties? They are often a result of similar groups living together in proto-nation states like Greek city states, so nationalism is developed by this proximity, which is increased when formal nation states are developed. Without this proximity, tribal groups would not feel the same loyalties to each other, suggesting that states and geographical closeness create the conditions for nationalism.

Framing

Tribalism is a prehistoric phenomenon which predates anything resembling a modern nation state, providing strong evidence, with a significant precedent, that nationalism existed before nation states, which are formed as a result of nationalist feeling.

Premises

1. Loyalty to your own group or tribe feels inherent, and is not created by nation states. 2. Nations can be formed as a result of these groups. 3. Many groups which feel a strong nationalism, such as Palestinians and Kurds, do not have a state, meaning nationalism must come first.

Rejecting the premises

Proponents


References

  1. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nationalism/#WhaNat

This page was last edited on Saturday, 20 Jun 2020 at 21:23 UTC

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more before voting ↑

Explore related arguments