argument top image

Will Donald Trump be re-elected? Show more Show less
Back to question

In 2016, billionaire realtor Donald Trump won the US Presidential election, confounding polling forecasts, expert opinion, and mainstream press predictions. In the intervening four years, Trump's leadership has divided the nation. His critics blame Trump for deepening social cleavages, and say he has legitimised racism, deepened economic inequality, and reversed crucial climate change legislation. Others support his re-election, citing his economic record and calling his America First policy vital in the age of uncertainty. So, will Donald Trump be re-elected?

Yes, Donald Trump will be re-elected Show more Show less

Donald Trump has proven himself as a strong President since he took up office in 2016. Much evidence suggests that his supporter numbers have grown, and will lead him to victory in the 2020 US election.
(1 of 2) Next position >

The Presidential incumbency rate suggests Donald Trump will be re-elected

Statistically, sitting Presidents are much more likely to be re-elected regardless of opinion poll results. This suggests Donald Trump will be re-elected in the 2020 election.

Context

History shows us that re-election of presidents is more common than not Opinion polls become irrelevant when we glance at empirical likelihoods

The Argument

Trump will win because voters are historically more likely to re-elect sitting presidents. This is proved by Regan, Obama, and Eisenhower.

Counter arguments

Previous presidents who were re-elected had increasing approval rates - Trump's are declining "It’s one thing to vote for someone you dislike, it’s another to vote for someone you think is a bad president. In other words, asking people whether they approve or disapprove of how the president is handling his job is going to be a better predictor of their vote than asking them whether they have a favorable opinion of a candidate" (Bernstein).

Proponents

Framing

Empirical evidence and likelihood models Historical voting patterns

Premises

US Election History

Rejecting the premises

There is no logical or warranted premise for this argument. Trump has a declining approval rate, and increasing rates were the only reason incumbent president's were re-elected in the past.

Further Reading

"Ronald Reagan, George W. Bush and Barack Obama experienced more modest increases, but increases nonetheless. Reagan’s approval had already increased significantly in 1983 as the country recovered from the punishing 1982 recession. But it increased about three more points in 1984 before he was easily reelected" (Sides).

References

This page was last edited on Tuesday, 13 Oct 2020 at 16:26 UTC

Explore related arguments