argument top image

< Back to question Who is Prince Philip? Show more Show less

The controversial figure is known as much for his controversial comments, as loyalty to Queen and country. But who really is he? An ancient deity? A hideous racist? Or a simple family man and national treasure?

Prince Philip is a family man Show more Show less

Married for 72 years, and a dedicated father? That love and loyalty should define the Prince's memory.
< (2 of 3) Next position >

Prince Philip is a dedicated father

Prince Philip raised four children with the Queen and has stuck by them through scandal, divorce, and even calls for their extradition. That kind of dedication is an absolute rarity.
< (2 of 3) Next argument >

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more before voting ↓

Proponents


Context

Prince Philip is the husband of Queen Elizabeth II, the current Queen of England. In the past couple of years he has taken a step back from Royal duties and therefore his relationship with his wife and his family has become even more unknown. As the patriarch of the Royal Family, Prince Philip is undoubtedly a man who commands respect and authority. Whether this translates into a good relationship with his children is, however, up for debate from different parties.

The Argument

As his wife is the Queen of England, some have argued that her role as head of State has meant that a lot of the family duties have been transferred to Prince Philip. As a result, he has been the parent who has had the most time to dedicate to bringing up his children. Historian Sally Bedell-Smith has argued that the Queen ''relied increasingly on her husband to make the major family decisions''. [1] Although there has been much media speculation regarding his relationship with his son Charles, there has been lots of positive media attention regarding his relationship with his only daughter Anne. The wife of a close friend of Prince Philip was quoted as saying ''[Philip] always had more fun with Anne. Charles is more like the Queen, while Anne is very like Prince Philip." [2] Prince Philip was especially involved with his youngest son's upbringing, and was even present at the birth itself, an unusual move at the time. According to Ingrid Seward's book, the Queen wanted Prince Philip present at the birth of their youngest son Edward, and in doing so they broke a royal tradition. [3]This illustrates that Philip was willing to approach fatherhood in a more progressive way, by becoming the first royal father to witness the birth of his child.

Counter arguments

In Jonathan Dimbleby's 1994 biography of Prince Charles, Prince Charles was quoted as saying that it was ''inevitably the nursery staff'' [4] who essentially brought him up. This suggests that Prince Philip was not as much of a hands on, dedicated father after all. It has been argued that Prince Philip was too harsh in his insistence that Charles attend his alma mater Gordonstoun instead of Eton. Charles reportedly hated the school and was subjected to bullying there. This suggests that Prince Philip is perhaps not such a dedicated father, as he did not listen to his child's wishes or understand his unhappiness.

Premises

[P1] Due to the Queen's position as head of state, a lot of familial decisions have been the responsibility of Prince Philip. This shows dedication and commitment. [P2] Prince Philip has had a famously strong relationship with his daughter Anne. [P3] Prince Philip has defied convention to be there for his children, such as when he was the first royal male present at the birth of their child.

Rejecting the premises


References

  1. https://www.townandcountrymag.com/society/tradition/a13051858/queen-elizabeth-ii-relationship-with-children/
  2. https://www.hellomagazine.com/royalty/2019081576263/princess-anne-special-bond-dad-prince-philip/
  3. https://www.independent.ie/style/celebrity/celebrity-news/britains-queen-elizabeth-was-the-first-to-break-royal-tradition-during-prince-edwards-birth-36322908.html
  4. https://www.townandcountrymag.com/society/tradition/a13051858/queen-elizabeth-ii-relationship-with-children/

This page was last edited on Wednesday, 1 Jul 2020 at 01:19 UTC

Explore related arguments