argument top image

< Back to question Who is Prince Philip? Show more Show less

The controversial figure is known as much for his controversial comments, as loyalty to Queen and country. But who really is he? An ancient deity? A hideous racist? Or a simple family man and national treasure?

Prince Philip is a controversial figure Show more Show less

For decades, Prince Philip's comments drew criticism for their offensive and insensitive nature.
(1 of 3) Next position >

Prince Philip is a philanderer

The press has long accused the Prince of having passionate affairs during his marriage, including with a showgirl in the 1950s.
< (3 of 3) Next argument >


Not sure yet? Read more before voting ↓


The Argument

Prince Philip is a deceitful philanderer who cheated on Queen Elizabeth on multiple occasions. In 1948, a photographer named Baron Nahum introduced Prince Philip to Patricia Kirkwood, a young showgirl. They met in Kirkwood’s dressing room at the London Hippodrome before Kirkwood’s performance. This meeting allegedly involved dinner and dancing all night, leaving Elizabeth at home alone and eight months pregnant.[1] After this meeting, Philip and Kirkwood met on at least seven more occasions. While Kirkwood continually denied any affair until her death, Philip never cleared her name. Since Prince Philip never denied the rumors, this makes it obvious that he lied about his relationship with Kirkwood.[2] Therefore, Prince Philip is a philanderer. Furthermore, Prince Philip has involved himself in the lives of other women throughout his marriage to Queen Elizabeth. In 1957, the Baltimore Sun released a story that Prince Philip was allegedly involved in an illicit relationship with an unnamed woman. Beyond these two affairs, the public accused Prince Philip of romantic connections to other performers like Helene Cordet, Merle Oberon, and Anna Massey. [3]With the number of accusations related to Prince Philip’s connections to women, there is obviously some truth in the allegations. This means that Prince Philip was unfaithful to his marriage and engaged in some sort of philanderous relationship.

Counter arguments

While Prince Philip never officially denied allegations, this does not mean that he was involved in any affairs. Since he is constantly under the scrutiny of the public eye, it is expected for news sources to accuse Philip of his relationship with other women. When journalists interviewed Philip about the accusations, he asked how he could ever go anywhere without security watching his every move.[2] Over 50 years have passed, and nobody has found any concrete evidence that supports the illicit allegations of Prince Philip. Therefore, Philip should not be seen as a philanderer but as a faithful husband.


[P1] Prince Philip has been accused of multiple affairs while married to Queen Elizabeth. [P2] Prince Philip did not deny any of the accusations. [P3] Since Philip did not deny any accusations, this means the accusations are true. Therefore, Prince Philip is a philanderer.

Rejecting the premises



This page was last edited on Sunday, 12 Jul 2020 at 19:06 UTC

Explore related arguments