Home Categories About
argument top image
Is taxation theft? Is taxation theft?
Yes, taxation is theft Yes, taxation is theft
No, taxation is not theft. No, taxation is not theft.
Taxation as theft is question-begging Taxation as theft is question-begging
Yes, taxation is theft, but theft can be justified Yes, taxation is theft, but theft can be justified
The government has no right to tax The government has no right to tax
Taxation is legal plunder Taxation is legal plunder
Not according to Social Contract Theory Not according to Social Contract Theory
Tax is an equalizing force, not a theft Tax is an equalizing force, not a theft
Pre-tax income does not belong to the taxpayer Pre-tax income does not belong to the taxpayer
Taxes determine incomes, not make up a part of them Taxes determine incomes, not make up a part of them
Property rights do not exist as natural rights but as social conventions Property rights do not exist as natural rights but as social conventions
Property is a state-granted privilege, that government can revoke Property is a state-granted privilege, that government can revoke
If property rights are justified on consequentialist grounds, they should not be viewed as absolute If property rights are justified on consequentialist grounds, they should not be viewed as absolute
Debate Mini Map

Is taxation theft?
Back to question

Yes, taxation is theft, but theft can be justified

< (4 of 4)

If property rights are justified on consequentialist grounds, they should not be viewed as absolute

Resource scarcity may necessitate some restrictions on individuals' ability to use certain resources. This is often used as a basis for a consequentialist justification of property rights, based on the notion that their absence would lead to social or economic disfunction. However, this leaves the door open to consequentialist justifications for the revocation or violation of property rights in certain situations.
< (3 of 3)

The Argument

Counter arguments

Premises

Rejecting the premises

References

This page was last edited on Sunday, 4 Oct 2020 at 02:31 UTC

Explore related arguments