argument top image

Should anime be adapted into live-action films? Show more Show less
Back to question

As anime grows more popular, more series have been adapted into live-action movies. They aim to service the fans of those anime, and bring the series to a wider audience. But they haven't always been met with good reception. With the rise of both anime and their live-action adaptations, the question is posed whether or not anime should stay in the realm of animation, or break into other media.

No, anime should actually not be adapted into live-action movies Show more Show less

Live-action anime movies have a whole host of drawbacks to them that make them not worth it.
< (2 of 2)

The purpose of live-action adaptations is just to make a quick, easy buck

There is no real artistic merit to a live-action animation, other than cheap fanservice. Film studios don't see or appreciate the story or medium for what it truly is; they only recognize the growing popularity of anime and see an opportunity to milk easy money out of fans.

The Argument

What exactly is the purpose of a live-action adaptation? It doesn't add anything new to the story. In fact, the driving factor behind these movies isn't some artistic film-making desire. These movies are actually just cash grabs, aimed at exploiting fans of an anime to take their money. For proof, look at Disney's live-action adaptations. With very few exceptions, they've been either lackluster or just plain bad. They do nothing new with the source material they've been given, and indeed sometimes make it worse. Fans accuse the company of merely making these films as easy ways to prey on nostalgia and rake in cash. There is no real artistic merit to them, just trying to make money of the same thing in a different skin.[1] The same principle applies to anime live-action movies. Studios know the popularity of certain anime. They target their fandoms and sell them an adaptation. In reality, they're not making something new, but rather finding a new way to make money from an old source.

Counter arguments

It's overly cynical to say that adaptations are just cash grabs. Yes, they're intended to make money--all movies are--but they also allow for genuine creative output by re-imagining familiar stories in new settings. Even though the article cited refers to criticisms of Disney's films, it also shows people, particularly those who worked on the films, who appreciate the art and the creative process that went into them.

Proponents

Premises

Rejecting the premises

References

  1. https://www.insider.com/how-disney-animators-feel-about-live-action-movie-remakes-2020-3
This page was last edited on Wednesday, 26 Aug 2020 at 14:34 UTC

Explore related arguments