argument top image

< Back to question Is a hotdog a sandwich? Show more Show less

The hotdog is a beloved meal that exists in many forms around the world, from Chicago dog, to the ballpark frank, the chilli dog, and on and on. A frankfurter placed within a bun with any variety of condiments in all sorts of combinations. But the question remains, is the hotdog a sandwich?

No, a hotdog is not a sandwich Show more Show less

A hot dog is like a sandwich, but should not be classified as such.
< (2 of 2)

A sandwich requires two pieces of bread

By definition, a sandwich requires two pieces of bread to be present with some sort of food in the middle. A hotdog is only one piece of bread with food in the middle, so it cannot qualify as a sandwich.
< (1 of 2) Next argument >

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more before voting ↓

Proponents


The Argument

A food item requires two pieces of bread in order to qualify in the category of "sandwich". This is according to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a hot dog is one piece of bread with meat and fillings inside. The mere fact that a single piece of bread has a unique shape does not make it a sandwich. A piece of toast with toppings would not be considered a sandwich, because it is a single piece of bread. A hot dog is the same thing, just with a specially shaped piece of bread. In fact, the definition of a hot dog in the dictionary is "a frankfurter with a typically mild flavor that is heated and usually served in a long split roll" [1]. This includes no mention of the multiple pieces of bread required for classification as a sandwich and does not even necessitate the use of bread at all as a critical part of designation as a hot dog. Thus, by nature, a hot dog would not qualify as a sandwich. Its own definition does not allow it to fall under that category and it should not be attempted to be placed there.

Counter arguments

Although the hot dog definition may not classify it as a sandwich, the definition of a sandwich certainly does. By definition of the dictionary, a sandwich considers a split bun with filling as a form of sandwich. It's a rectangle/square situation, but it still allows hot dogs to be classified as sandwiches.

Premises

[P1] A hot dog is not defined the same as a sandwich [P2] A hot dog should not be defined as a sandwich

Rejecting the premises


References

  1. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/hotdog

This page was last edited on Friday, 5 Jun 2020 at 01:11 UTC

Explore related arguments