argument top image

< Back to question Why does Monopoly destroy families? Show more Show less

It's no secret that gaming in families can deepen longstanding conflicts. But it's Monopoly that has historically caused even the most sedate auntie to try and send the whole group to jail. Is it the Chance? The Community Chest? The natural grievances brought out by an inflated property market?

The intensity of the situation Show more Show less

When do families play Monopoly? When they're trapped together in confined spaces, desperately looking for something to end the inane smalltalk. It's a situation that lends itself to disaster.
< (2 of 5) Next position >

Being stuck indoors with family is never going to end well

You've finished all the puzzles, run out of charades prompts, and it's still raining outside. The long-neglected shelf of board games is calling your name, and one stands out to you: Monopoly. It'll be fun, right? The circumstances that lead to playing Monopoly bring out the worst in people.
< (1 of 1) Next argument >

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more before voting ↓

Proponents


The Argument

Let’s be real: Monopoly is never the first choice. Nobody ever thinks, “Hey, you know what sounds like a good way to spend the next five hours? Playing a frustrating miniature version of capitalism with my family.” Rather, Monopoly is often the last resort when there is nothing left to do on a rainy day, or when you’ve already played all the fun board games on family night. Thus, the circumstances that lead families to play Monopoly set them up for failure. Already bored, restless, and forced to spend time together, families are primed and ready to be torn apart by this game. Evidently, Monopoly cannot take the blame for all of the familial conflicts it is famous for. Rather, it merely lights the fuse on the bomb created by preexisting circumstances. If a family freely chose to play Monopoly in a stress-free setting (and, perhaps most importantly, one they could get out of if they so desired,) perhaps the game would not have such notoriety.

Counter arguments

This is not the only situation that inspires families to play Monopoly.

Premises

Rejecting the premises


References


    This page was last edited on Saturday, 4 Jul 2020 at 04:17 UTC