argument top image

Should athletes kneel during the national anthem? Show more Show less
Back to question

In 2016, the San Francisco 49ers' quarterback, Colin Kaepernick, first took a knee during the national anthem playing before his teams' first preseason games. Since then, many other athletes have also taken a knee in protest against police violence and brutality in America. What exactly does this protest mean? Is it disrespectful to the country and the sport, or is it a legitimate form of protest against a country that has never treated its minorities fairly?

Yes, athletes should kneel as a legitimate form of protest Show more Show less

America has never been fair to people of color. Athletes aren't just celebrities. They are ordinary citizens who face discrimination as well. It is perfectly legitimate for them to take a knee and protest every injustice in their lives because a country and an anthem do not deserve unequivocal support.
(1 of 2) Next position >

Taking a knee is a powerful form of protest

When athletes take a knee right before a game, the action will be broadcasted to thousands of Americans around the country. This is an excellent opportunity for athletes to use their platform for good and use a small but profound action to inspire anger and change for the better.

The Argument

Colin Kaepernick kneeling on the field during the 2016 football season's pre-game anthems had much more widespread implications than the one game itself: it sparked a powerful movement of protest. The story became national news almost immediately, and since then, many other football stars have taken to kneeling before their games.[1] The Jacksonville Jaguars took a knee before their game against the Baltimore Ravens, the Eagles and the Giants both took a knee before their game against each other, and dozens of members of the Buffalo Broncos took a knee. Many of the biggest names in football, from Terry Bradshaw to Tom Brady, have joined in to voice their support for the movement all because of Kaepernick’s first action. During the protests in the aftermath of the death of George Floyd, thousands of protestors around the country, inspired by Kaepernick’s actions from nearly four years ago, also joined in on taking a knee.[2] What all of this shows is just how influential and powerful football players could be. With millions of people watching the biggest NFL games, a football player is not just a part of one of the teams playing to win. They are a public figure whose opinions can bring actual change. Taking the knee was a powerful strategy for Kaepernick to bring attention to a pertinent issue. Today, when football is just as popular, taking a knee remains an important way for athletes to express their views. Without a doubt, police violence is a pressing issue facing America. As of October 2020, the police have already been responsible for the death of 861 Americans, with 28% of those being African Americans despite them only making up 13% of the population.[3] Kaepernick called attention to an important issue by kneeling.

Counter arguments

Taking a knee is an ineffective form of protest because it distracts the discussion away from the actual issue. In America, the flag and anthem are seen by most as symbols of pride that should be respected without exception. The fact that, after Kaepernick knelt, the majority of the discussion was not actually about the issue of police violence itself but about whether or not kneeling was legitimate should show that the discourse generated is not actually helpful to the movement. Kneeling serves as a distraction to the actual problems that African Americans face by making the otherwise popular cause of equality a controversial issue. Regardless of what Kaepernick and his subsequent supporters knelt for and whether they were un-American, most of the audience's initial reaction was one of shock and disapproval, not one of celebration and awareness. Public figures, from President Obama to Dabo Swinney, the head coach of Clemson University’s football team, have all come out to voice their disapproval of kneeling in front of an anthem that stands for peace, security, liberty, and so much more than just racist America.[4][5] Police brutality is a legitimate issue, but taking a knee is not the right way to talk about it.

Proponents

Premises

[P1] Football has a big platform, which makes kneeling widely seen and very influential. [P2] Police brutality is a pressing issue.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] The controversial nature of kneeling itself distracts discourse away from the actual issue.

References

  1. https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2020/06/01/colin-kaepernick-kneeling-history/
  2. https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2017/09/why-the-nfl-is-protesting/540927/
  3. https://mappingpoliceviolence.org/
  4. https://www.businessinsider.com/clemson-football-coach-dabo-swinney-colin-kaepernick-protest-speech-2016-9
  5. https://www.cnn.com/2016/09/05/politics/barack-obama-colin-kaepernick/index.html

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more ↑

Discuss

This page was last edited on Monday, 26 Oct 2020 at 00:49 UTC

Explore related arguments