convo top image

Should there be reparations for slavery?

More than 150 years since the end of slavery, racial inequality is still evident in the United States. Black Americans have an average household wealth just a tenth of white families, face housing and banking discrimination, and higher policing. Reparations for slavery is either a path towards equality or a path to further division.

No, there should not be reparations for slavery

The logistics, ethics, and effects of reparations are troubling. Reparations are impractical and divisive in practice.

Reparations are a racist policy

The policy places blame of past injustices on several generations of white people who had nothing to do with slavery. It is racist to punish them for a historical act that the vast majority today condemn as racist.

Reparations are costly

The cost of reparations is potentially trillions of dollars. With an already growing deficit and no clear way to fund the effort, reparations are too costly to implement.

Reparations are logistically impractical

Not all black Americans descended from slaves, so tracing back who is deserving of reparations is complicated. Also, if the system isn't careful it could fall victim to exploitation.

Yes, we need reparations for slavery

The effects of slavery are still felt today, with apparent effects on black Americans and communities. Reparations would help heal the lasting effects of slavery.

Reparations would address the racial wealth gap

The gap between the average incomes of black and white Americans is large. Paying out reparations would help close this gap.

Reparations is the ethical thing to do

The years of cruelty, torture, and exploitation experienced by slaves is still evident in the racial inequity in society. Reparations are a means of making amends for the atrocities.

Instead of reparations, poverty should be addressed for all Americans

The lasting effects of slavery are primarily felt through poverty. However, black Americans are not the only demographic to suffer from poverty.

Policy addressing poverty would have greater effects on racial inequality

The real issue affecting black Americans is poverty, but they are not the only ones. The wealth inequality and poverty rate in the US plagues much of society. Sweeping economic reforms are more effective than reparations in addressing this disparity.

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more ↑

Discuss

This page was last edited on Saturday, 17 Oct 2020 at 15:14 UTC