Opinion
Lab

See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.

Gender

AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
Log in to see how you compare
Share to
https://www.parlia.com/o/all-body-types-are-beautiful

5 comments

Against
I suppose all body types have a sort of natural beauty. In the same sense that an insect's eye is beautiful to behold up close, and in the sense that all humans are incredibly impressive, complex systems. But ultimately, beauty is entirely subjective; Someone can especially beautiful to me yet not to you. This goes for any subject of beauty. Not just body types. (e.g. a gun can be beautiful to one person and not another)
··
Mixed
Julianne5y ago
Since all body types have the potential to be beautiful to someone, yet it's true that beauty does have to be subjective, I'm mixed. I am quite swayed by the idea that beauty could be said to be inherent in the stunning complexity of all bodies' arrangements (not to mention the sheer wonder of their existence), regardless of type.
··
For
**The subjectivity of beauty makes this a difficult claim to defend but, if we interpret it more contextually, there is reason to agree.** The subjectivity of beauty easily lends itself to the human body. Whether an absolute claim can be made for an inherently subjective discussion, however, is another question entirely. - Let's say we claim that all body types are beautiful, if they are each beautiful to at least one person. What stops us then, from making an equivalent claim to the contrary: that no body types are beautiful simply because there might be someone out there who does not appreciate one of each? - Deciding that the human body itself is a marvel and an item of beauty, does that make all body types are beautiful by default - i.e., merely because they are human bodies? Again, whether the human body is an item of beauty is itself open to subjectivity, and this argument only adds another dimension to the discussion. - Some might argue that beauty can be objective, given genetic and cultural bases upon which common traits and items are considered beautiful at a virtually universal degree. The variety of opinions on the beauty of human bodies - collective, conscious, and subconscious - implies that this is not likely to apply here. The real reason I agree with this statement, however, is because I decided to interpret it less literally. There is a certain social context in which we discuss the implications of appreciating and depreciating diverse human appearances. When we say 'all body types are beautiful', it can be argued that what we're really saying is: _All body types have the potential to be beautiful to someone, and all bodies deserve to appear beautiful to those they belong to._ In other words, when we make this claim, we are often articulating our support for body positivity than establishing a literal absolute. We are claiming that body types should not have to adhere to an objective social standard, thus welcoming and _celebrating_ the subjectivity I highlighted before. Thus, the claim in its most fundamental form may not be verifiable, but its colloquial cousin can be.
··
Against
IXH8265y ago
**pretty isn't the price you pay to exist in this world, you deserve respect regardless..** - bodies don't need to be beautiful. i believe [body neutrality](https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.insider.com/what-is-body-neutrality-explainer-2020-8%3famp) is a more productive way of expressing that our bodies are perfect how they are even if they don't adhere to standards of beauty. however, even the idea of them needing to function "properly" implies we must be productive or useful to be worth something. i feel it's a step in the right direction, but we are a far cry from learning to love our bodies for what they are outside of what they can provide for others. - we cannot ignore the [standards of beauty](https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.teenvogue.com/story/standard-issues-white-supremacy-capitalism-influence-beauty/amp) since they are worth examining. they are proof that we have created a world in which we are categorised as attractive or not based on some standards which are ever-changing. this dictates how we are treated, so to ignore that people are treated differently for how they look is to sugar coat the reality rather than confronting it. - ugliness is associated with evil and prettiness with good, as seen even just in every disney movie. in reality, appearance means nothing in terms of someone's character. it should not be a taboo to not care about being "pretty" and if you do then it shouldn't be assumed to be for anyone but you. the standards are objective, but beauty really is in the eye of the beholder and subjective. this means people should focus on being beautiful to themselves and the people who really matter because making everyone happy is impossible and tiring.
··
Against
Can't we just accept this reality that all body types are not beautiful..? Can't we please ? I mean C'mon BEAUTY depends on the body type... Yeah I mean if someone is chubby we can't exactly compliment them that they are BEAUTIFUL..and the fact is everybody knows this..we just can't accept and that's completely okay.. I believe.. I'm just trying to pouring my thoughts here... I hope you guys are also doing the same...
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!