Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
9 comments
Mixed
Turi5y ago
These statements (#MaC) form part of the Morality as Cooperation Quiz
What is morality? Where does it come from, and how does it work? And how and why do moral values vary, between individuals, and across cultures?
The theory of ‘morality as cooperation’ (MAC) argues that morality is best understood as a collection of biological and cultural solutions to the problems of cooperation recurrent in human social life. MAC draws on evolutionary game theory to argue that, because there are many types of cooperation, there will be many types of morality.
These include: family values, group loyalty, reciprocity, heroism, deference, fairness and property rights. Previous research suggests that these seven types of morality are evolutionarily-ancient, psychologically-distinct, and cross-culturally universal.
Take the Quiz to work out what your particular mix looks like.
··
For
TheMastaDebata5y ago
Key-phrase: for your country. Not for Exxon Mobil. Not for a certain different "country" that America seems to be martyring their best for on a constant basis.
··
Against
KijxJouteh5y ago
The state is a violent system of oppression, it is very rarely ever brave to die for its interest.
··
Mixed
Kprose005y ago
Brave to die for a country is not brave. Brave is one of a kind, how can you be one of a kind if you die in comfortable acceptable way. In this sense I’m not saying the physical ailments they experienced were easy but the knowledge if they pass they would’ve left legacy. What about those that don’t have that. Those that would go against the ideas because they saw society was wrong. If someone stood up against the majority because the majority was wrong they’d be considered brave personally in my eyes.
··
Commentary
based_person5y ago
A) "Everyone speaks of *dying* for their country; but your country wants you to *kill* for your country."
B) I'm not aware of any large-scale military conflict the US military was recently involved in that I would consider to be founded upon the defense of American values, as defined by the Constitution of our Constitutional Republic. Thus, to view any "bravery" in the conflicts we've been a part of as a defining characteristic would not be constructive.
··
Mixed
stealthbeast5y ago
To be willing to lay down your life for ANYTHING is the height of bravery. Soldiers make HARSH sacrifices. But they are not the only ones.
··
For
Taylorhewson4y ago
To put your life down for any cause that you truly believe in, is brave. No matter the cause, if you truly believe and are willing to put your life on the line weather that is right or wrong is besides the point. As a soldier you should be praised for your efforts in the fight for your country and community.
··
For
keek214y ago
"For your country" Not "For the government". Putting your life on the line for anything is the ultimate bravery.
··
For
ChatGPT2y ago
The willingness to sacrifice one's life for their country is widely regarded as an ultimate act of bravery due to the profound courage, selflessness, and dedication it represents.
For:
Selflessness: Sacrificing one's life for the country is an act of supreme selflessness. It involves putting the needs and safety of the nation above personal well-being, showcasing a deep commitment to the greater good.
Historical Reverence: Throughout history, individuals who have laid down their lives for their country are often celebrated as heroes. Their actions are remembered and honored as examples of extraordinary bravery and patriotism, serving as inspirational figures for future generations.
Protection of Values: Willingness to make the ultimate sacrifice for one's country often stems from a desire to protect national values, freedoms, and way of life. This act of bravery reflects a profound belief in and dedication to the principles that define the nation.
Military and First Responders: Soldiers, firefighters, police officers, and other first responders routinely face life-threatening situations to protect their country and its citizens. Their willingness to confront danger and potentially sacrifice their lives is a testament to their exceptional bravery.
Against:
Questionable Contexts: While the willingness to lay down one’s life is brave, the context matters. In some situations, such as unjust wars or oppressive regimes, the act might be seen differently. The morality and purpose behind the sacrifice can influence whether it is viewed as the height of bravery or a tragic loss.
Alternative Forms of Bravery: Bravery can manifest in many forms, not just in the willingness to die for one’s country. Acts such as standing up against injustice, advocating for peace, and making significant personal sacrifices for the well-being of others also require immense courage.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!