Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
8 comments
For
georgiakeys5y ago
TL;DR Colonialism wasn’t all bad, especially for the British.
It is a common narrative to suggest that only the British Elite benefited from colonialism, however this is not the case, in fact even those not directly involved in colonialism have benefited and these benefits continue to trickle down today. Colonialism can be said to have fuelled the Industrial Revolution, which saw huge economic growth within the UK, not only did this mean improved infrastructure but it also meant increased health and wellbeing across the nation.
··
Turi5y ago
No doubt you're right, colonialism was - for the very most part - good for the colonisers. But do you have data on the trickle down? Or on colonialism's role in triggering the Industrial Revolution?
··
Against
Meg_Stalham5y ago
**TL;DR- At the time, (for the British) colonialism was seen as a good thing. But it's 2021, and as a society, we *have* to acknowledge how terrible and evil colonialism was.**
Colonialism is easily one of the worst atrocities that has ever happened in human history. It enabled murder, enslavement, exploitation, discrimination, massacre, and more, and it's effects have lasted up to this day. In the 19th century, colonial rule was established by countries such as Britain over continents they saw as inferior and 'uncivilised'. The methods and practices of colonialism are explained below by *Time4Africa*:
> [The so-called mission of 'civilisation' was uniformly carried out in the following manner:
1) Seizure and confiscation of all land.
2) Pillaging and theft of all natural assets.
3) Systematic murder, (ethnic cleansing), of dissident tribes – Bushmen & Hottentots.
4) The creation of the Slave Trade.
5) Introduction of Race Laws to suppress and dehumanise.
6) The imposition of Christianity. In name but NOT in practice.
7) Limitation of freedom of movement and education – a.k.a. Apartheid.
8) The pretence that the indigenous population was inferior – unter-mensch.
9) Institutionalisation of a Baas culture, with the superiority of the White man.
10) The lasting impoverishment, to this day, of the entire population of the Continent.] (https://zen4africa.com/2017/12/04/10-reasons-why-colonialism-was-bad-bad-bad/)
This atrocity cannot be justified, and is extremely rarely even discussed in school history classes. Britain is always painted as heroic, colonisers such as Christopher Columbus are constantly glorified, and the history curriculum in general is very Eurocentric and one-sided, hence failing to expose the inherently diabolical nature of colonialism.
The British Empire and colonialism are nothing to be proud of.
··
Turi5y ago
There's one data point that strikes me about India.
In the 18th Century, when the East India Company first turned up, India represented 24% of global GDP.
When the British left in 1947, it was 2%.
From Shashi Tharoor's ['An Era of Darkness'](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/32618967-an-era-of-darkness)
··
CITYDRAGON5y ago
Maybe other countries upped the ante
··
Nsoper194y ago
Interesting how you only look at British colonisation? What about all the times Britain itself has been colonised? By the Romans, by the Anglo-Saxons, by the vikings, by the Normans?
The British were just the best at colonialism in recent times. That is really the only difference between them and basically any other nation you care to mention.
The Bantu people colonised southern Africa, the Mughals colonised the Indian subcontinent, the Maoris colonised New Zealand, I could go on and on.
Seems like you are trying to push an agenda here? Also conflating Columbus and British colonisation is anachronistic and misleading.
··
Against
martair5y ago
Historically, colonial dominance has included massacres such as murder, torture, and abuse of innocent people. However, pointing out these wrongs is inadequate to justify how colonialism is wrong in a unique way. Murder, suffering, and slavery are all incorrect, regardless of whether they occur during colonial rule.
When we think about colonization, we also consider how it has impacted indigenous peoples, and the results have been largely negative. However, we're likely missing something. Colonization may have a detrimental effect on colonizers, their descendants, and more recent settlers whose ancestors may not have been part of the colonization's early stages.
··
Against
centaur20205y ago
UMMM?? There are actually people who think Colonialism was ok??
Going over to another country..say like New Guinea , people who have never seen a white man....raping their land and all its resources, stealing their property and possessions, killing and torturing the men, women and children, wiping out their religions, destroying their culture, their beliefs, setting fire to their buildings, churches and houses, then forcing them to accept your beliefs, your religion, your way of thinking or be killed. Building prisons instead of bridges. If you think thats ok, quick go get some help, your sick!!
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!