Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
3 comments
For
meglev245y ago
**TL;DR - I think it is shameful how little effort English-native speakers put into learning another language, and I think this has to change**
We all know that British stereotype right? Goes abroad and instead of learning a few words in the local language to get by, just speak English but louder to communicate. It is not only not helpful but also very ignorant and arrogant to assume everyone will help in English. Yes, of course, English is the global language, but it doesn’t mean we should juts sit back and relax when it comes to language learning.
About [1/7 people speak English to a communicative level] (https://www.babbel.com/en/magazine/how-many-people-speak-english-and-where-is-it-spoken), but only 360 million are native speakers. Language learning is not easy task, but it is done by so many to create international opportunities, whilst English speaking nations just take it for granted. Using the UK as an example, only [23% of citizens know a second language] (https://www.rosettastone.co.uk/magazine/how-do-the-british-feel-about-languages/) at least adequately. Yet so many of us believe learning a new language will improve job opportunity, mental health and communication capabilities. We treat learning a language as a dream whilst the rest of the world see it as a reality. I believe that this needs changing and even if its just 20 words when you go on holiday, this stereotype needs to change.
··
Against
BretonRok5y ago
English because learning a new language unless they need to is unnecessary. English is after all the worlds primary language. Most places that you go will not only have the original translation but also the English translation underneath. And besides no one should put any effort into anything they don’t want to if I don’t want to learn Spanish that’s fine and if you argument is that it helps you to be more cultured that’s ridiculous. If anything people who do not speak English should learn English not because they should suppress the culture but because it would be very beneficial to them because many things are in English in many countries.
··
Commentary
Jonathanese4y ago
English is the largest hub language in the world.
What does this mean? If someone who speaks native Hawaiian meets with someone who speaks Icelandic, they do not choose to speak Hawaiian nor Icelandic to talk to each other. They choose English, because it is very likely English is a second or third language to them. Icelandic and Hawaiian are endpoint languages in this case. English is the hub language.
While languages like Mandarin may be spoken by more people, it is restricted mostly to east Asia. Most east Asian countries also teach English, so English is often used as an intermediate language.
Generally, if you learn a second language, it is to learn a language that acts as a better hub to speak with a greater variety of people. That is, you generally learn a second language to learn a hub language of similar size or larger.
If you speak English, there is little actual need to learn another language for simple communication purposes, as it is the largest hub language, and thus can be spoken to the widest variety of people. This is why native English-speakers are comparatively unlikely to be fluent in other languages.
And in the case of North America, nearly the entire continent speaks English, and is isolated by oceans. In Europe, you could take a 6 hour drive and go from Polish to German to Dutch to French. In the United States, you could drive for a week and only ever hear English.
Learning a second language is an absolute must for the sake of things like linguistic development and understanding of other cultures. But the Anglosphere's lack of language fluency doesn't come from laziness, it comes more from lack of necessity.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!