Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
4 comments
For
Brandoflores5y ago
Four years of the Trump administration has damaged the reputation of the Republican Party through an apparent decline of their democratic values. This concern has escalated drastically during the Trump administration’s last year in office through several attempts to hinder the democratic process, which raises national security concerns at home and abroad.
Former U.S. defense secretaries published a severe opinion piece against outgoing President Donald Trump in January 2021, driven by national concerns over the imposition of martial law to devoid the 2020 election (Swan, 2020). The former secretaries were also concern that the Defense Department political appointees loyal to President Trump had been attempting to obstruct the Biden transition after canceling briefings with the incoming administration and cause institutional turmoil by pulling out of Afghanistan and Iraq without a viable exit solution (Detsch, 2021).
This is not solely a Trump administration issue; attempts by Republican policymakers to overturn election results in the contested states won by Democratic nominee Joe Biden represented a drastic escalation of a trend toward Republican authoritarianism. Despite Both Democratic and Republican election officials across the country have reported minimal irregularities during the 2020 election, 2/3 of House Republicans and a majority of Republican state’s Attorney Generals support the presidents remarks of election fraud (Ingraham, 2020). This election fraud resentment led to the storming of the capital which not only threatens the livelihoods of elected officials, but also exposed potential exploits that Russia, China, and Iran could take advantage of in the upcoming protests planned in all 50 states (Lee, 2021).
Carter, A. (2021, January 03). Opinion | All 10 living former defense secretaries: Involving the military in election disputes would cross into dangerous territory. Retrieved January 15, 2021, from https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/10-former-defense-secretaries-military-peaceful-transfer-of-power/2021/01/03/2a23d52e-4c4d-11eb-a9f4-0e668b9772ba_story.html
Detsch, J. (2021, January 04). Defense Secretaries Worried About a Trump Power Grab. Retrieved January 15, 2021, from https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/01/04/defense-secretaries-trump-pentagon-power-grab/
Ingraham, C. (2020, December 14). Analysis | GOP efforts to overturn election may do lasting harm to democracy, political scientists warn. Retrieved January 15, 2021, from https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/12/14/republicans-trump-election-democracy-texas-lawsuit/
Lee, Y. (2021, January 08). China and Russia could exploit chaos in the U.S. after Capitol riot, says a national security expert. Retrieved January 15, 2021, from https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/08/china-and-russia-could-exploit-chaos-following-us-capitol-riot-prof.html
Swan, J. (2020, December 19). Officials increasingly alarmed about Trump's power grab. Retrieved January 15, 2021, from https://www.axios.com/trump-officials-alarmed-overturn-election-results-a844d1d2-acb2-47a9-87ce-ac579458b1ea.html
··
Against
sofiawells5y ago
First of all, I agree with you that the Republicans we see storming the capitol building are definitely a threat to national security. It is also true that, since 1994, far-right extremist groups have accounted for more domestic terrorist acts and plots than any other group (1). However, as much as I personally do not find myself in alignment with most Republican values, I'm not sure I'm completely convinced that it is the entire Republican Party we should be concerned about.
For all of the Republicans who still approve of Trump, and even of the capitol riot, there are also plenty who do not. I've even heard rumors of a party split, but as that has not happened yet, that means that there are still a decent amount of people who still identify with the Republican Party because there is no other option (that aligns with their beliefs) but do not support the extremism that has been happening as of late. Even McConnell, a staunch conservative, has expressed grievances about the state that Trump has imposed upon the Republican Party and is open to impeaching him.
I'd argue that the true culprit here is the two party system, which has the potential to trigger our tribalistic instincts, forcing people to pick the group they most identify with and fiercely defend it to preserve their own interests. It requires people to choose what they feel most passionate about and potentially sacrifice everything else on the ballot. This contributes to much of the extremism that we see today, as it creates an us vs them dynamic where, as unproductive as it sounds, the more scrutiny a party (or members thereof) is under (as the Republican Party has been under the past few years), the firmer its members stand by it.
And I think that lumping everyone that belongs to a broad party together as a national threat poses the risk of 1. encouraging the left to disregard any information or perspectives that come from the right, and 2. to cause the right to become defensive and take up an even harsher position.
So, ultimately, although the opinion that much of the Republican Party is straying into dangerous territory may have some merit, it might be more helpful to think of this issue and its solution in terms of expanding the options people can choose from so they don't have to justify the extremism in order to vote the way they want to on, say, taxes, rather than invalidating a good amount of people's views by grouping them together with extremists as a national threat. Several GOP politicians have announced that they are leaving the Republican Party and registering as independent. If there were another option that better represented these people, perhaps more would be willing to make the switch, making it easier to label exactly what group poses a threat to national security.
1. https://www.csis.org/analysis/escalating-terrorism-problem-united-states
··
MakenaLikewise5y ago
I couldn't agree more. Regardless of political persuasion, painting the other side of the aisle (which recent voter turnout revealed to be quite literally half the country) with a single brushstroke detrimentally ignores ideological complexities and variations to the point where politics regresses from a practice in self-reflection to a tribal war of my sports team vs your sports team.
··
For
ywang5y ago
All political parties have internal differences. The defining factor of a party, however, depends on how it governs. A party becomes dangerous when it governs dangerously, not when every member of the party becomes dangerous. The current GOP has become significantly compromised by the Trump cult of personality. The erosion has taken over enough of the party that it can no longer govern responsibly. Despite its many sane members, the modern-day GOP represents a national security threat.
The corruption of the GOP starts at the grassroots. Despite the reckless lame-duck session, the GOP base has stood with the former President. The majority of GOP voters consider Trump a good influence and would favor him as a candidate for 2024. [1] More alarmingly, around 30% of GOP voters believe in the QAnon and endorse political violence in some form. [2] Their preferences cements the GOP as a reckless party in the foreseeable future.
One can point out the other side of the statistics. Many GOP voters do not like conspiracy theories or violence. However, the irrational fraction has so far exercised far more influence within the party even after the January 6 insurrection. Despite flirting with conspiracy theories and trying to overturn the 2020 election, the Arizona GOP Chairwoman Kelli Ward won her reelection within the party. [3] Ronna "Not Romney” McDaniel remained as the GOP national committee chairwoman with Trump's endorsement. [4] Even with significant evidence, only ten Representatives and seven Senators from the GOP voted to impeach or convict Trump.
Many rational GOP voters and politicians want a serious GOP. The United States of America needs and deserves a serious GOP. However, the party has so far failed to reckon with its increasing descent into madness. Before that happens, the GOP will, unfortunately, represent a national security threat.
[1]. Talev, Margaret, and David Nather. 2021. "GOP Voters Choose Trump — Again". Axios, , 2021. https://www.axios.com/trump-mcconnell-republican-voters-69b27794-5557-44fe-80a6-d481adf15adf.html.
[2]. Cox, Daniel. 2021. "After The Ballots Are Counted: Conspiracies, Political Violence, And American Exceptionalism". Findings From The January 2021 American Perspectives Survey. Survey Center on American Life. https://www.americansurveycenter.org/research/after-the-ballots-are-counted-conspiracies-political-violence-and-american-exceptionalism/.
[3]. Armus, Teo. 2021. "Kelli Ward Led A Push To Overturn Biden’S Victory. Now Her Own Win As Arizona GOP Chair Is Being Questioned.". The Washington Post, , 2021. https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/01/28/arizona-gop-election-kelli-ward/.
[4]. Karni, Annie, and Mike Baker. 2021. "An Emboldened Extremist Wing Flexes Its Power In A Leaderless G.O.P.". The Washington Post, , 2021. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/01/us/politics/republicans-trump-ronna-mcdaniel.html.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!