Opinion
Lab

See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.

Gender

AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
Log in to see how you compare
Share to
https://www.parlia.com/o/short-selling-should-be-illegal

3 comments

For
AVetsch5y ago
Short-Selling stocks is an immoral marketing tactic. For those who need some context, let me explain what short-selling is. Short-selling is when a financer speculates that a stock will go down by a certain time, particularly one that the marketer owns. As soon as this is realized, the short-seller would sell the stock at the current price. Then once the stock went down, will buy back the stock at the lower price and keep the remaining money that is earned. To make this more comprehensive, imagine if I borrowed your iPhone for a week because I knew Apple will lower the cost of your iPhone at their stores. I then sell your iPhone at the current price, then once the price went down, would pay for the same type of iPhone I borrowed from you to give it back, and keep the remaining money I earned as a profit. To some marketers, short-selling is a common tactic in the marketplace. After all, it's just making money. Is there anything wrong with that? Furthermore, short-selling already has a high risk/reward ratio, per James Chen on Investopedia: It offers big profits, but losses can mount if stock incidentally goes up, especially way up. Going back to the iPhone example, if the price of the iPhone I borrowed and sold incidentally went up, then I would be in a financial situation. So, if short-selling already has some risks that could suffice as punishment, then why bother going to all this trouble placing a ban on it. That's because by short-selling a stock, a marketer is gambling that a business will fail. In the wake of the pandemic, particularly on the heels of the Gamestop stock fiasco, people found themselves to have more than enough time to get into financing and trading. Since numerous stocks went down because almost every business had to grind to a halt, short-selling went through the roof. According to a PDF document by Travis Whitmore of State Street, European countries placed bans on short-selling. Banning short-selling, Whitmore quotes the SEC, will also benefit the market by protecting " 'the integrity and quality of the securities market and strengthen investor confidence' ". Short sellers see economic downturns such as the 2008 financial crises as golden opportunities to profit, though it is at the expense of people losing their money. But proponents of short-selling also insist that bans would negatively affect stocks. However, Whitmore notes that a paper published by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York found no credible evidence of this claim. If anything the Gamestop stock drama has demonstrated, it is that numerous Americans feel that the financial system is geared towards maintaining economic divisions between the rich and the poor. And the market needs a lot of regulation, especially if everybody, no matter their wealth status, wants to get in on investing stocks. Banning short selling will not instantly fix the market, but it would be a great start to helping make the market manageable for everyone. CITATIONS: Chen, James. “Short Selling.” Investopedia, 28 Jan. 2021, www.investopedia.com/terms/s/shortselling.asp. Whitmore, Travis. “The Effectiveness of Short-Selling Bans.” Statestreet.Com, State Street Corporation, 2020, www.statestreet.com/content/dam/statestreet/documents/Articles/The_Effectiveness_of_Short-Selling_Bans_Final.pdf.
··
Mixed
**Short selling is just another market gamble with a different name and tactic.** [Short selling](https://www.npr.org/2021/01/28/961619848/so-what-is-short-selling-an-explainer) is a controversial concept in that it's a little unconventional. Essentially, it’s a [gamble dependent upon the market](https://www.fool.com/investing/how-to-invest/stocks/shorting-a-stock-meaning/). Short sellers have an intuition, or they get some undisclosed insight (illegal), on which they wage their bet. Their bet translates to the borrowing of company shares that they believe will fall in price and then selling those shares. This results in one of two ways: → If the [shares value drops](https://fortune.com/2021/01/28/what-is-short-selling-shorting-stocks-short-squeeze-what-happens-after-wallstreetbets-reddit-companies-hedge-funds-retail-investing-faq/), the short seller profits from the difference when they return the borrowed shares. → If the [shares value increases](https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/29/short-selling-what-it-is-why-its-risky-and-how-a-squeeze-happens.html), the short seller actually has to come out of pocket to buy the shares back before they can return them to the broker. This method is in complete opposition to a [long position](https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/long.asp), in which an asset is purchased for the purpose of accruing value over time. Yet, when considered, both are risky, and it’s no surprise because both are reliant on the constantly fluctuating market. Does short selling heighten the probability of illegal sharing happening? Absolutely, but every gamble has a lackluster downside. However, [short selling can also](https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/investing/shorting-a-stock) unveil fraud, and bring poorly run companies to light.
··
Commentary
mayowa_o5y ago
**The calls to ban the practice of short-selling have existed for over 400 years.** [Short-selling bans or restrictions](https://www.optiver.com/insights/news-articles/short-selling-bans/) are often enacted during times of great market stress in an attempt to prevent stock prices from falling further. These bans usually restrict market participants from selling shares that they do not already own. Such examples of short-selling bans include: • _1610_: [Isaac Le Maire](https://www.investorschronicle.co.uk/education/2021/02/22/lessons-from-history-short-selling-bans-are-ill-advised/) was one of the founders of the Dutch East India Company. As a response to being removed from the board of directors, in 1609 he formed a secret group to short shares in the company. When shareholders discovered their plan a year later, the first-ever regulation against short-selling was put in place, effected in the Amsterdam stock exchange; • _2008-2009_: When the Lehman Brothers went bankrupt in 2008, [regulators](https://www.investorschronicle.co.uk/education/2021/02/22/lessons-from-history-short-selling-bans-are-ill-advised/) such as the US’ Securities and Exchange Commission and the UK’s Financial Services Authority placed several restrictions on short-selling. They believed this would help to steady the market after the significant financial crash; • _2020_: In the early months of 2020, stock prices were tumbling due to the fear and uncertainty surrounding the Covid-19 pandemic. Consequently, [regulators across Europe](https://www.ft.com/content/14a95d33-b4db-4a9a-a4e4-834a45c23228) implemented temporary bans on short-selling to counter this market volatility.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!