Opinion
Lab

See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.

Gender

AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
Log in to see how you compare
Share to
https://www.parlia.com/o/strict-zoning-codes-are-harmful

5 comments

For
ywang5y ago
Cities in the U.S. use zoning codes to regulate land use. They can mandate the type of constructions allowed on a piece of land through these regulations. Often, that leads to neighborhoods exclusive to single-family homes. [1] While city planning necessitates some land regulation (no one should build residential homes next to a chemical plant, etc), strict zoning codes in many U.S. cities today are harmful. These regulations have detrimental effects on housing affordability, racial justice, and economic prosperity. Strict zoning codes decrease housing affordability. The prevalence of single-family zones mandates low density in some of the most popular cities in the United States. This under-utilization of land leads to fewer new houses constructed and thus depressed supply of housing. Consequently, zoning codes and other land regulations correlate strongly with elevated housing prices. They likely bear responsibility for these high prices. [2] Moreover, strict zoning codes often encourage owners of high-end houses to expand or renovate their properties. These practices can further elevate the values of the housing market without increasing the supply of it. [3] Therefore, strict zoning codes depress housing affordability in multiple ways and make expensive cities more expensive. Strict zoning codes have a particularly deterrent effect on African Americans. Ever since the 20th century, cities have used zoning codes to explicitly or implicitly enforce racial segregation. The protection of single-family zones often shuts African Americans out of comfortable living conditions and sufficient resources. As a result, African Americans of all income levels are more likely to live next to pollution sources and develop health conditions. [4] The segregation of neighborhoods also perpetuates the segregation of schools. As a result, racially segregated schools tend to deliver fewer resources to black children and other children of other minority groups. [5] Thus, strict zoning codes have long hindered the process of racial equity. Strict zoning codes also hurt the macro-economy. Due to the low densities, cities often fail to realize their full economic potential. Some of the most expensive cities, such as New York or San Francisco, are also the most productive places with significant economic activities. However, the lack of affordable housing has discouraged many potential skilled residents. When not all productive laborers can fit in productive places for an artificial reason, the labor market has an inefficient equilibrium. This mismatch has prevented potential economic growth. According to one estimate, the strict zoning codes in three cities (New York, San Jose, and San Francisco) have restricted about a 10% growth of the U.S. economy. [6] Strict zoning codes protect single-family houses at the expense of housing availability, racial justice, and national economic growth. For these reasons, it is a harmful policy. [1]. Badger, Emily. 2018. "The Bipartisan Cry Of ‘Not In My Backyard’", , 2018. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/21/upshot/home-ownership-nimby-bipartisan.html. [2]. Glaeser, Edward L., and Joseph E. Gyourko. 2002. "The Impact Of Zoning On Housing Affordability". SSRN Electronic Journal. doi:10.2139/ssrn.302388. [3]. Schuetz, Jenny. 2019. "Restrictive Zoning Is Impeding DC’S Goal To Build More Housing". The Avenue. The Brookings Institute. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2019/10/08/restrictive-zoning-is-impeding-dcs-goal-to-build-more-housing/. [4]. Brennan, Maya, Emily Peiffer, and Kimberly Burrowes. 2019. "How Zoning Shapes Our Lives". Housing Matters. https://housingmatters.urban.org/articles/how-zoning-shapes-our-lives. [5]. Rothwell, Jonathan. 2012. "Housing Costs, Zoning, And Access To High-Scoring Schools". The Brookings Institute. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/0419_school_inequality_rothwell.pdf. [6]. Hsieh, Chang-Tai, and Enrico Moretti. 2019. "Housing Constraints And Spatial Misallocation". American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 11 (2): 1-39. doi:10.1257/mac.20170388.
··
Turi5y ago
Great argument, very well made. The UK is one of the few developed world countries without zoning laws. Their absence doesn't necessarily improve things - we hand far too much power to local councils. They are often whimsical and unpredictable in their decision-making, they're open to influence, they often lack the appropriate expertise and are often antagonistic towards each other. So you can end up with a pocket-by-pocket approach to urban planning rather than a city-wide strategy...
··
ywang5y ago
That is interesting. I actually don't know much about housing policies in the UK. My general opinion on land regulation is relatively libertarian (excluding some necessary health related regulations). However, I am sure there would be unintended consequences for that as well.
··
AVetsch5y ago
Strict zoning laws have also been blamed for the housing crises in California (https://www.vox.com/2016/4/23/11490758/oakland-housing-crisis). When big tech companies became proponent in San Francisco, this caused the average rent fees or the prices of owning a residence to skyrocket. But the housing crises was also caused by strict zoning laws that prevent more houses in the area from being built. Since there San Francisco has to keep a limited supply of houses or apartments to compensate the inclusion of big tech companies. CITATIONS: Lee, Timothy. “Bad Housing Laws Have Turned San Francisco's Tech Boom into a Crisis for Oakland.” Vox, 23 Apr. 2016, www.vox.com/2016/4/23/11490758/oakland-housing-crisis.
··
ywang5y ago
Same thing in Seattle. I think the mayor there is trying or already changed some of them. I think Minneapolis is also an interesting case study to watch. They eliminated all single family housing zones a few years ago, under a broad urban planning agenda called Minneapolis 2040. I think it is promising but only time will tell. Read more about Minneapolis 2040 here: https://minneapolis2040.com/
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!