Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
6 comments
For
will123455y ago
**TL;DR: Transgender people are the gender that they identify with and should be allowed in that selected sexes bathroom**
[Studies have shown] (https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/05/180524112351.htm) that transgender adolescent brain activity more resembles that of the desired gender. If they identify as a specific gender and feel like a specific gender then they should be allowed in a bathroom of their choosing. It would be highly distressing for a transgender person to be forced into a bathroom in which they do no feel comfortable. [Transgender women experience depression] (https://www.hindawi.com/journals/drt/2014/394283/) at a higher rate than the general population. Attitudes around which bathroom they should go in are likely to contribute to this. If the transgender person feels comfortable going into the bathroom of the gender they identify with, then they should be allowed to.
··
For
freyaehope5y ago
**TW Sexual violence**
**TL;DR: Preventing transgender people from using their preferred bathrooms puts them at risk of harm**
The most prevalent argument against transgender people using the bathrooms of their choice claims that this would put more cisgender women at [risk of sexual violence](https://www.vox.com/2016/5/5/11592908/transgender-bathroom-laws-rights). Such opponents fear that this ruling could enable cisgender, heterosexual male predators to ‘disguise’ themselves as transgender women in order to sexually assault women in this confined space. This speculation has been found unwarranted: [the Equality Federation](https://time.com/4314896/transgender-bathroom-bill-male-predators-argument/) records no increase in this behaviour in places with LGBTQ+ anti-discrimination laws in place (where transgender people are officially allowed to use whichever bathroom they feel most comfortable in).
Instead, transgender people are put at risk of sexual violence by not being allowed to use the bathrooms of their reassigned gender. Sadly, nearly half of transgender men and women experience sexual assault in their lifetime. The [2015 US Transgender survey](https://vawnet.org/sc/serving-trans-and-non-binary-survivors-domestic-and-sexual-violence/violence-against-trans-and) found that 47% of respondents had experienced sexual assault in their lifetime, with higher figures for trans POC. The activist [Christine Burns](https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-36395646) argues that "It's clearly not safe to require somebody who presents as a woman to go into a men's toilet. The evidence is, from the cases that have happened, is that real assault takes place, real people get hurt”. As a society, we should ensure that transgender people can choose which bathroom they use in order to protect them from harm.
··
DumbAnkney4y ago
just create bathrooms for trans. simple as that. by letting self Id be a factor for bathrooms and locker rooms you're opening the door for predators.
··
ELW3y ago
This may not be relevant where you are, but the most recent census for England and Wales in 2021 found that just 0.5% of people identify as non-binary or transgender. That's about 300,000 people (out of about 60 million people representing about 90% of the UK).
In comparison, women and girls make up 30 million people. Rape Crisis England & Wales says that:
• 1 in 6 children (16%) have been sexually abused
• 1 in 4 women (25%) have been sexually assaulted or raped
• 1 out of 6 rapes was perpetrated by a stranger
If strangers committing a minority of sexual abuse is true in general, there are around 1.2 million women and girls (representing 2% of the public) who have been subject to sexual abuse from a stranger. This is 15x more than all non-binary and transgender people put together. So if there is a conflict between the interests of these groups, no ethical or rational argument can be made for prioritising trans people.
Which is likely, as Rape Crisis England and Wales also says that:
• 5 out of 6 rapes (83%) are not reported to the police
• 98% of convicted sex offenders are men
Is there any reason to believe that other sex crimes are more likely to be reported to the police? Or that trans women are less likely to offend than men? If anything, isn't it likely that a hostile climate of opinion towards perceived transphobia is likely to discourage reporting? And what about the refusal by the government, many institutions and, increasingly, the public to recognise many acts of voyeurism and exhibitionism committed by non-binary and transgender people as sex crimes?
··
Mixed
csb5y ago
Wherever they feel most comfortable is where they should go; a lot of trans people don't "pass" as their gender but they still are that gender
··
Against
DumbAnkney4y ago
transgenders should either create their own spaces or use the spaces designated to their birth sex. Identity does not give you the right to go into the opposite spaces simply because of feelings and surgeries. bathrooms, sports, and locker rooms are separated by sex for a reason. Women, for example, don't feel safe with having bio men in their locker rooms. Take a look at the Wi Spa incident. Also, consider how a school in Virginia tried to cover up trans student r@ping two female students because the school let them into the bathroom they identified with. Does this mean all trans are bad? No, absolutely not. But that doesn't mean we should leave the door open. Find a way to create a space that keeps both trans and men and women safe.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!