Opinion
Lab

See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.

Gender

AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
Log in to see how you compare
Share to
https://www.parlia.com/o/declawing-cat-is-animal-abuse

6 comments

For
**TL;DR -- Declawing a cat is body mutilation, and can lead to severe physical and mental distress.** The process of declawing a cat involves *amputation of part of the toe bone*. That's right -- when you declaw your cat, you are cutting off some of their body parts. Cats walk on their toes, and by amputating part of their toe bones, [we're basically crippling them](https://www.declawing.com/the-truth-about-declawing) and setting them up for a lifetime of physical problems: Infections, lameness, and back pain, just to name a few. > ["If performed on a human being, declawing would be like cutting off each finger at the last knuckle."](https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/declawing-cats-far-worse-manicure) In other words, declawing a cat is **body mutilation**. Imagine living without the tips of your fingers or toes: you might find it difficult to climb, to grab, to balance, to sprint -- all the things that makes a cat a cat. And not only is there physical trauma, but imagine how your cat feels when it wakes up to find that a vital part of its body has been forcibly removed? How would *you* feel? Disoriented? Victimized? Despairing? The cat might try to do the things they used to do -- jumping up onto furniture, expecting for their claws to dig in and help them up, but slipping off and (painfully) hitting the floor because their claws are no longer there. They might feel like a failure, like they're no longer a real cat, because they can no longer do the things that come naturally to them. For cats, their claws are a part of their identity. Imagine having your (insert most precious body part here) forcibly removed… you might feel as if you're no longer whole, no longer a *person*. Think of the psychological harm this could cause: A loss of ability, a loss of identity. Not to mention the long-term physical issues that could plague you the rest of your life. If this was done to a human, the doctor who performed the surgery would be arrested and lose their medical license. Why, then, do we continue to allow this barbaric practice on our most beloved companions? Declawing a cat is animal abuse, and there is absolutely no justification for it.
··
Turi5y ago
Had no idea... 😿
··
Against
CYD5y ago
If you have more than one cat and they are kept indoors, having them declawed is the responsible thing to do. They don't need their front claws. The only thing they'll do with them is use their claws against each other when they spar with each other, which is inevitable.
··
**TL;DR -- Responsible pet owners teach their pets not to use their claws the wrong way. Declawing is the easy way out, but there are no easy ways out in good parenting.** No, the *responsible* thing to do is to properly trim your cats' claws every week or so. It takes more effort, but it's better than mutilating and psychologically damaging your cat. If you don't want to put in that kind of effort, then you shouldn't be a pet owner. I have three cats. One I've had since he was a *very* young kitten, and I've always trimmed his claws without issue because he trusts me. The second is more aggressive and actually used to bite and scratch when I tried to trim his claws. But eventually he calmed down -- I taught him through rewards that aggression doesn't earn him treats, but being still does. The third is a kitten and is still learning, but he's getting used to it as well. It takes patience, nurturing, and parenting to be a cat owner. Just like being a parent to your children. You teach them not to do bad things. They learn. Alternatively, you can have your vet or a groomer trim their claws if you are unable or unwilling to do so yourself. **Edited** for clarity and to explain things without the unnecessary sarcasm.
··
CYD5y ago
Removing a child's hands?!? GTFOH No one is talking about removing a cat's paws. You obviously don't own any cats, and haven't spent much time around them. If you did, you'd realize that they won't want sit still every week or so for claw trimming, which brings with it it's own risks. A once-and-done procedure leads to much happier pets. And yeah, I read your post. I thought it was garbage written by someone who doesn't live with cats.
··
Mixed
It's an accessory, but their claws are safety devices. They're evolved to try to grab stuff if they slip and fall off something. They're evolved to want to maintain their claws. Their claws are their tools. Like our fingers. So if it is at all possible to solve whatever problem you're having, WITHOUT taking a knife to the cat, you probably should. I dunno if I'd call it flat out animal abuse, but I would at least call it unnecessary.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!