Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
11 comments
Often don't? Yes. Can never? No. The difficulty depends on where they come from and how old they are when they first arrive, but even the most hopeless looking cases can thrive.
There's an assumption here that being "fully integrated," which is vague in itself, is always a good thing.
🙌- If the UK had had 'full integration' we'd still only be eating boiled meat.
Depends on the society. Middle-Easteners integrating into Western Societies is always a positive. Westerners integrating into Middle-Eastern societies rarely is.
They why immigrate to another society if integrating to them is not good?
There's a difference between "can't" and "shouldn't".
Ideally, people would be able to be fully integrated. In reality, your success will very much be determined by which country you live in. Western countries, while often criticized, are often more open in this regard.
In countries like the far east you could have several generations of history and still never be considered among their peers. In some cases simply having brown hair instead of black will earn you a "foreigner" title.
They will never be integrated, I have seen 2nd 3rd and 4th generation and they still don't integrate.
TL;DR - This depends on how you define 'full integration'.
There are several facets to a person's belonging within a country, and the how we rank these factors will result in varying standards for 'full integration' - such as:
This is by no means an exhaustive list. 'Full integration' can be defined by any number of the above and more, and the answer to whether first-generation immigrants can achieve it will decidedly differ. An interesting example can illustrate this:
I believe they can’t however It’s not to say they are a negative factor or influence on the country.
Non-integration does not mean non-appreciation
It isn't an inherently bad thing to not be fully integrated - it is okay to have more than one culture.
With this perspective, you are able to have strong attachments to multiple cultures without abandoning yourself and losing your identity.
Greater appreciation of cultures - especially in a country where the first generation immigrant culture is a minority ethnic group.
When westerners immigrate to other countries, they don't always integrate with the local culture and are not pressured to do so. They are called 'expatriates' as opposed to immigrants and have less burdens to integrate, compared to non-western people immigrating to western countries.
I'm a first-generation immigrant--born in the United States but chose to move to Mexico. I know the history and food as well or better than most Mexicans. My Spanish is sufficient to have conversations about relatively abstract ideas. But I will never be culturally "Mexican" because I can never have the experience of growing up here.
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!