Opinion
Lab

See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.

Gender

AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
Log in to see how you compare
Share to
https://www.parlia.com/o/homework-is-good-thing

5 comments

Against
RB5y ago
Homework places undue pressure on children of any age. The value of a balanced work and home life as means of managing stress and improving quality of living is well recognised. This has been highlighted by the recent need to work from home where possible: while some find the opportunity to exercise autonomy in their working day beneficial, others find that it is much harder to set boundaries between work and personal time. Your office is your home and you cannot leave it. The two things become enmeshed and it makes it very, very difficult to detach yourself at the end of the working day. So why then do we assume that this is a good thing for children? It’s the worst of both worlds: not only are they required to work a six hour day, they are then required to bring that work into their home and are penalised when they don’t deliver. There is none of the autonomy that may benefit an adult working from home. There is also an inherent inequality in it. While some students might have access to a dedicated workspace; a quiet environment and technical resources that allow them to produce a ‘higher’ quality of work more easily, others do not. The pressure to succeed can foster stress and anxiety that negatively effects wellbeing and sleep which will have a knock on effect on engagement in class, overall hindering learning. Taking a very cynical view of education, this sets a poor precedent for a child’s expectations of working life. In a broader and more damaging sense it establishes this anxiety as a norm. School is a formative experience and should be a place where children feel encouraged to learn and grow- not somewhere that they learn to meet often arbitrary targets for the sake of avoiding admonishment. SOURCES: https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/working-from-home-mental-health_n_5afd88e2e4b0a59b4e014602 https://news.stanford.edu/2014/03/10/too-much-homework-031014/
··
I think the problem is not with 'homework' per se, but maybe what we associate homework with, and this is the fault of the education system. What I mean is that homework, as Alban Woods very correctly says, provides a link between what you learn at school and real life, contextualising learning, but this does not have to do with the fact that we do our homework 'at home'. Currently, the education system conveys the wrong idea of the proper function of 'homework' and what it should do for the students. For homework to be effective in learning, it has to be reconfigured and changed into something more hands-on and relatable, not just a series of exercises / mundane tasks that do not motivate the student and do not relate to their everyday experience. Students should have homework, but they should have homework that reflects how they can actually place what they learn in real life, and this I think will motivate them better. In this form, homework will be more engaging and not considered a mandatory boring task you have to complete daily.
··
For
I completely agree with this statement. Extra curricular education forms the bedrock for building passions for subject areas and develops self discipline in students that enable them to be better prepared for future studies in higher educational fields. Additionally, ‘homework activities relate what is learned in school to children's lives outside of school’ (Atkinson, 2021) and thus contextualises their learning. Something that then solidifies their understanding and contributes to increased attainment rates. As a result, this enables students to develop further and achieve more. Although value should be placed upon a consistent work and home life balance, one hour of homework in a specific subject area throughout a period of five years study, equates to an extra year in education in that particular focus area. The benefits of producing home based work however does have its limits and a balance must be achieved for it to be effective. For example, students according to figures last year, students were committing to ‘two and half hours of homework a day’ (UCL, 2020) and this is rather excessive. Overworking contributes to disengagement and then the whole positive idea of encouraging students to develop their passions at home becomes redundant. In order for homework to be a successful component for any educational curriculum there must be balance and considerations when it comes to deadlines. If these key pillars are met, homework most certainly is a positive part of any students educational diet. Why Homework Is Important | Scholastic. 2021. Why Homework Is Important | Scholastic. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.scholastic.com/teachers/articles/teaching-content/homework-why-it-important/. [Accessed 30 January 2021]. UCL. 2021. Children doing 2.5 hours’ schoolwork a day on average | UCL News - UCL – University College London. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2020/jun/children-doing-25-hours-schoolwork-day-average. [Accessed 30 January 2021].
··
Against
The ability to control a kid OUTSIDE of school is just not the type of power teachers should ever be allowed to have. edit: At the very least, we shouldn't be handing it willy nilly to any old teacher of any old subject. I understand that you can't dedicate the school day to reading an entire book; They need to take it home. Some science research can only be done outside the school. Some art projects, like involving paint that must dry, are best worked at intermittently over time in a home environment. But homework in compulsory schools should be a practice used very sparingly, only with certain subjects, and only with teachers who have proven themselves especially respectful with their students time. Remember, we're talking about the literal, and unregulated ability to control a kid outside of school. We take this reality WAY too lightly. When you get 7+ new teachers each year, all giving homework with basically 0 regulation to its fairness, the odds that one of them will singlehandedly ruin your entire year with their overinflated sense of worth of their pet subject is WAY too high. Some of the homework practices I needed to endure were downright cruel and I really really didn't need to lose my entire childhood to this bullshit. I should emphasize, this is for compulsory school. You know, the one that's 40% education and 60% babysitting... You already consume a ludicrous amount of a child's time. You shouldn't have the power to ruin a kid's entire day AND their entire evening, every single day. Fucking pick one. At least a schoolday can END... There is no way to escape from the agony that is a ludicrously unreasonable homework assignment. You will be anxiety ridden until you either complete it at which you will be exhausted so fuck the rest of your day I guess, or resign to not fully completing it, take the loss to your grade, and suffer the fate of having everyone in your life call you a bad student because you couldn't emotionally cope with a fourth page of trinomial equations. The problem with teachers, is that most of them liked school growing up. That's not your only demographic, teachers. You are literally hurting people with your unethical homework practices and any time anyone tries to talk about it they get called whiny. Talk about a feeling of powerlessness.
··
Against
School should stay at school, work should stay at work. Kids need time to relax and enjoy their time.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!