Opinion
Lab

See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.

Gender

AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
Log in to see how you compare
Share to
https://www.parlia.com/o/sex-and-gender-are-different

9 comments

For
A person's **sex** is how you know who has what and who to mate with. A person's **gender** is an arbitrary social construct. It is a set of stereotypes of how males and females "should" act, dress, what they should like/dislike, etc.
··
Against
Sg915y ago
Well what is gender. Is it a reflection of a persons biological sex or a masculinity/femininity spectrum? If it's a spectrum then how many genders are there? Everyone falls on different areas of that spectrum. There are plenty of cis women who are more masculine than the average man. There are also plently of cis men who are more feminine than your average woman. Do we have different gender identites for every person? At that point gender becomes obsolete. Do we break down the spectrum into different sections? Well that what if someone identifying as a cis man falls more on the feminine side than a demi-girl (or whatever a semi-feminine man is called). Is the cis man wrong about who he is? Either gender correlates with sex or gender is obsolete.
··
I think you're completely correct -- gender, as a modern concept, is pretty much obsolete. So it ought to just be stricken from society and replaced with a more spectrum-centered mindset.
··
Sg915y ago
No, the idea of gender being a spectrum should be stricken from society and gender should remain a reflection of ones biological sex.
··
We already have a word that is a reflection of one's biological sex. It's called "sex." We need a word for society's stereotypes. That's called "gender."
··
This is what I'm hearing from you: 'Gender' is being treated as a very complex subject. 'Sex' is dead simple and completely objective. If we could just all agree that gender and sex are synonyms, then we'd get to avoid a whole lot of needless frustration and confusion. I... agree that the subject is complex. I even agree that I don't feel like dealing with it. But if you make these two words synonyms, we're just gonna need to invent another word, because we NEED a word that means what gender mean (as opposed to sex). Regardless of how you feel about trans issues, you have a lot of use in differentiating between "sex" and "gender".
··
For
Whether you support trans people or not is irrelevant. If gender and sex mean exactly the same thing, then we're just gonna need to invent a new word to describe what we mean when we refer to "gender". Seeing as language evolves over time, adding nuance between the words "sex" versus "gender" is just useful. The most important thing is that everyone understands what everyone else is saying. Differentiating sex and gender helps us do this better.
··
Against
To argue that an interpretation of gender, distinct from sex, holds any significance is to argue the validity of gender stereotypes. Just freaking live your life the way you want to. But realize you don't have the right to dictate how everyone else has to interact with you.
··
Granted, but then you don't get to dictate how people react if you misgender them.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!