Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
6 comments
For
msiacotos5y ago
I think it would be more appropriate to say that technology changes creativity. When we are given a certain set of tools we create a certain set of outcomes. When the tools change we make new things. This just means that the way we express creatively changes. The old ways atrophy and new ideas flourish.
··
LeeAnn5y ago
Yes, Melanie.
While I do agree with this opinion, I also feel that it can be interpreted further. Especially in the way you suggested and have done - technology is now a new and different tool that can and certainly has changed how people express themselves creatively.
More specifically, technology has changed the way people are now expressing themselves through art. I feel that this especially true since the COVID pandemic started. Artists from all over the world are finding different ways to express themselves and their art through various mediums of technology, which in turn gives way to some very innovative concepts and ideas.
Also, I'm not entirely sure that I agree with the first part of your statement, "The old ways atrophy..." I suppose it depends on the context in which an old idea/concept is considered "atrophy."
··
For
ellikara915y ago
Technology has definitely created a space where creativity can bloom. For me, it all depends on the way you use technology and the infinite possibilities that technology provides. We wouldn't even be able to have so many creative media without the existence of technology, which has been part of people's lives for centuries.
One case in point is art. The development and existence of art would not be possible without technology. Paintings would not have been possible, and nor would the design relieves of artists like the Romantic William Blake, whose 'etching the copperplates of his illuminated books' startle even today, and constitute a point of constant enquiry by 'museums and publishers' alike, as Robert N. Essick and Joseph Viscomi observe.
Another example is painters like the Impressionists, whose creativity was enabled by technology itself. As Randy Rieland wonders, 'Where would the Impressionists have been without the invention of portable paint tubes that enabled them to paint outdoors? Who would have heard of Andy Warhol without silkscreen printing?'. It is very true that technology has changed our lives and shaped everything about the world that we live in, including the way we express ourselves.
In a fundamental way, technology also enhances creativity by the way it opens up the doors of knowledge. Google and other search engines like Google have made possible our access to unlimited resources and sites where we can expose ourselves to an enormous spectrum of thoughts, ideas and media.
Matt Stefl and Andrew Rohm claim that the '[w]e would hate to think of where we would be' without the internet', meaning 'without the millions of smart people and organizations freely sharing their insights, ideas, and solutions with the world', even though we must be mindful of how we use what we have got. Indeed, so many people use the internet and discover parts of their identities by working more on different skills and competencies. According to James Ingram, everyone has the chance to 'hone' their skills and share them around through platforms like YouTube, among many other choices. As a consequence, technology has led to the development of so many jobs, scientific disciplines, academic progress, entrepreneurship, traveling, tourism, and so much more.
All these have definitely supplies spaces for creativity and innovation, and have given us tools to think in different ways and for different purposes. Technology has also reduced distance and time in terms of research and creative endeavours, enabling people to share their creativity with the whole world.
Works Cited
Ingram, James, 'Information and imagination: why technology isn’t killing creativity' (2018) <https://www.raconteur.net/creativity-technology/> [accessed 29 January 2021].
Essick, Robert N. and Joseph Viscomi, 'An Inquiry into William Blake’s Method of Color Printing' (2002) <http://bq.blakearchive.org/35.3.essick> [accessed 28 January 2021].
Rieland, Randy, '7 Ways Technology is Changing How Art is Made' (2014) <https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/7-ways-technology-is-changing-how-art-is-made-180952472/> [accessed 28 January 2021].
Stefl, Matt and Andrew Rohm, 'Is the Internet killing your creative potential? Lessons from the Art of Paper Airplane Making' (2017)<https://gbr.pepperdine.edu/2017/04/is-the-internet-killing-your-creative-potential/> [accessed 29 January 2021].
··
Against
sanjana5y ago
Technology makes our lives easier. It is convenient. It makes our actions faster and more efficient. Technology as a result presents us with ideas and actions with minimum effort.
Creativity is a concept that has no boundaries, no rules. Creativity is limited when things are made easily available to us. Making a bookmark (creative) is unnecessary when you are reading on a kindle. Memorizing numbers with creative narratives is unnecessary because all our numbers are saved on our phones.
Creativity thrives in challenging, laborious situations. The technology eliminates or minimizes such situations. A person would be more creative and authentic in decorating their room without technology like Pinterest or pre-collated visual mood boards.
Laborious tasks like puzzles, chess, and painting require more creativity because they do not use any form of technology.
··
ellikara915y ago
It is actually a fact that puzzles, painting, chess, etc. are a form of technology, created through technology and requiring technology as media of entertainment/creativity. Technology is not necessarily only related to the Internet or gadgets, but encompasses so many things in our daily lives.
··
LeeAnn5y ago
Agreed!
At the end of the day we need to remember that technology is a collection of various tools (such as goods or services) that have been invented by us - using our skills, to make our lives easier and more efficient in achieving our objectives.
In addition, today we get various types of technology such as communication, construction, product, medical, architecture, business, education and information.
So puzzles, painting, chess, etc. can definitely be considered as a form of technology.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!