Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
5 comments
For
Hatty5y ago
Before getting into this opinion, I just want to warn that this may be triggering for people who have recently experienced loss.
Time does not heal all wounds, in fact time can allow for either the worsening of the effects of a wound such as grief, or can result in individuals learning how to cope with the loss of a loved one; but is coping healing?
*Worsening of the Wound*
Much like a physical wound, the wound of losing a loved one can have a variety of outcomes. Firstly, over time the wound may be able to heal by itself, much like a scratch or a gash. However, some wounds are so great that they require further help and support in order to treat the wound. This could be due to the wound getting worse by becoming infected. Therefore, in terms of grief, the wound left in some individuals may fester and worsen the psychological effects an individual is experiencing due to this grief. Resulting from this, any amount of time can pass, be it five, ten or twenty years, and the wound may still be there or be worse than before. The individual may need support in the form of therapy, for example, and without this support for the loss of a loved one, time will have no positive effect on the pain an individual is in from this loss.
*Is Coping Healing?*
When grieving, I have found that grieving is about learning to cope with the loss of a loved one and with that person not being in your life anymore. But I do not consider that healing. You can still see pictures, books, or listen to music that reminds you of that special person. When you do a variety of emotions may surface such as happiness in that memory but also sadness in never being able to share more memories with that person and missing them. Learning to cope when all these emotions surface is, in my opinion, a part of the grieving process but that hole is still there and the scar left from that wound still exists. So no matter how much time has passed, that wound can still slightly re-open and the reminder of those feelings of loss still exist which is why I don't consider coping with those emotions as healing. To me healing means complete restoration where as coping is coming to terms with all the emotions you will feel throughout time that will remind you of the person you have lost.
··
JenReneeGilley5y ago
Well said -- and very, very true.
Time can entirely change one's heart, too. Losing a loved one, experiencing betrayal, undergoing trama, failing in one's most precious goals... It can really take a toll on one's perception of life, other people, society, or even the world. The person's entire outlook may change, or even their very personality. It may result in the loss of innocence for young kids -- where they once regarded the world with curiosity and wonder, they now observe it with trepidation and scorn.
And sometimes, people don't even want to heal. They either feel like they don't deserve it -- that this is somehow a divine or karmic punishment -- or they feel guilty for moving on, like they're leaving behind the person they've lost, or abandoning other people who are also suffering. Still others believe that this must be their place in life -- that they must suffer so other people don't have to -- so they hide their pain and never allow their wounds to heal.
Or -- on the more cynical side -- some people even hold onto grief because it makes them feel entitled to display negative emotions, or to appear "victimized" in some way. They do this to either get attention, to gain sympathy and gifts / money / privileges, or simply to make themselves feel better. But even in this case, at the heart of it, the person is acting out because they are suffering -- that wound won't heal because they won't stop picking at it, and it frustrates them that they still feel pain from the wound, but they still keep perpetuating it anyway, looping themselves into a cycle of pain and negative behavior.
But yeah, excellent points you've made, especially about coping not being the same as healing. Coping with a wound means that it's a constant in one's life -- even if the person can "forget" about it for a little while, it will always be there in the subconscious, surfacing on occasion to remind the person that they're still in pain, and then retreating to await another opportune moment when it can again whisper words of melancholy, hopelessness, and / or fear. The person has to learn how to deal with this wound whenever it flares back up, and either distract themself from it, or soothe it back into dormancy.
On a (somewhat) lighter note: I was attracted to this Opinion piece because of its title, which immediately reminded me of a line from one of my favorite Nightwish songs, *For the Heart I Once Had*, which is actually *very* appropriate to this topic: It's about a person who experiences repeated heartbreak, and it eventually takes from them their heart and innocence. The lyrics also heavily imply a loss of innocence due to coming into adulthood, and learning that the world is not as full of wonder as when they were a child. This leaves the person scarred and constantly looking back to a time in which their heart was as light as snow. Anyway, the line in question is: "Time will not heal a Dead Boy's scars / time will kill." Since I'm entirely shameless in my desire to share my favorite songs, [here's a link to the song on YouTube] (https://youtu.be/1bZN_4NkbUo). (Btw if this this isn't allowed, I'll promptly edit and remove the link).
··
For
LeeAnn5y ago
Hi, Hatty! I agree with you in that time does not heal all wounds, especially within the context of losing a loved one. In fact, in a lot of ways this can be the most painful of all scars when it comes to healing, or as you put it coping.
What's more, we know and understand that healing is essentially when someone or something is made better, to put it simply. But when one loses a loved one that hurt or scar (on the inside) that you feel on the inside never really goes away. It's always there, but maybe not as strong as when the initial loss happened.
So no, time does not heal all wounds. It just helps us to better cope with that type of loss.
··
Against
ellikara915y ago
Great points on this topic. For me, though, healing does not necessarily mean disappearing and forgetting. Just like a physical trauma or a wound that may leave a scar, mental trauma and/or a loss can heal over time, which means that in this case (of proper healing, and not something that leaves to deep-seated traumas by deterioration) pain would no longer have a devastating effect on a person's life. Pain from a trauma like this will not 'control' the life of a person in the way it does when it is fresh. The expression 'Time heals all wounds' pertains to the fact that the blood and pain of trauma leaves its place to a memory of it, and even some long-term effects on the mind and the body, just like a healed wound would. And even if the wound on the body disappears completely, it always leaves a trace in the subconscious of what happened and where the trauma was. So I think, in a sense, healing really is learning to go on with the memories that you have.
··
JenReneeGilley5y ago
Fair enough. There's also the argument that "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger."
Tbh, I don't think there's a definitive, black-or-white answer as to whether or not time heals all wounds. I feel like it's completely situational and dependent on the person -- where one person might be able to handle suffering better, another might find it too overwhelming to be able to move on.
There's also the presence (or absence) of mental disorders to consider, which may disrupt the normal grieving process and cause the affected person to get trapped in or fixate on the "anger" or "depression" stages. A person's [personality type] (https://www.16personalities.com/personality-types) also plays a vital role in determining their level of fortitude and perseverence. Having or lacking a strong support network also makes a difference -- and in order for time to heal, their support network needs to be *patient*, and stick with them the whole way through. Having people give up on you halfway in only cuts the wound deeper.
So, yeah. Perhaps the best way to look at it is to understand that everyone is different, and what one person can handle, another person may be incapable of handling.
On a side note, I get *very* frustrated when someone says "well, *I* was able to do X just fine, so you have no excuse to not be able to do it." It's one of the most ignorant and insensitive things I've ever heard. Please, for the love of (insert object of worship here), *do not* ever say anything like this to anyone, *especially* not to someone who is experiencing grief or trauma. It sets up unrealistic expectations for someone to cope and heal in exactly the same way that you do, when more likely than not, their situation is different than yours -- which means they face disadvantages that you might not even have any concept of. What's worse is that it causes the other person to beat themself up needlessly for not being able to handle things the same way as you do. It isn't fair to force a fish to climb a tree -- it just simply can't be done, and all it does is hurts the fish's self-esteem.
... Anyway, yeah. After thinking about it, I'd actually change my vote to "Neutral" because it's not a simple black-or-white answer. Depending on who you are, either one could be right.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!