Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
13 comments
Against
Turi5y ago
**TL;DR: If 'whiteness' symbolises the dominant culture, Jews are still an ethnic minority**
Despite broad levels of acceptance and success across many Western societies, Jews are still seen as different, and are still subject to discrimination.
In Britain, there is a growing tendency particularly from the Left (see David Baddiel's [Jews Don't Count](https://harpercollins.co.uk/products/jews-dont-count-david-baddiel)), to treat anti-semitism as a 'lesser' prejudice on the premise that Jews as a whole have been successful in British society.
··
Mixed
Jonathanese5y ago
Jews are diverse due to the refugees who fled to places like Europe.
Most Jews in the US are largely white-passing since most fled from Europe and therefore would be grouped with white people with regard to certain social issues such as police brutality, redlining, racial income disparity, and many/most others. Most in the US have German or Polish surnames as well, meaning things like name-based resume discrimination aren't especially strong-either.
The social issues the Jewish people face are generally more point-to-point rather than broad, systemic issues. It is a couple of specific groups of people who specifically seek out and target them.
I can't comment on issues regarding the broader world, as it includes Israel/Palestine relations which I am not versed in, as well as how other countries may view their Jewish citizens.
··
Against
Sg915y ago
Jewdaism is a religion. Blacks, whites and anything in-between can be Jewish.
As for ethnically Jewish, no they're Middle-Eastern. Closer to Arabic than White.
··
Nsoper194y ago
Well they are Semitic, which is the same ethno-linguistic group as Arabs. Melanin is of very little relevance.
··
Against
KijxJouteh5y ago
Judaism is a religion or an ethnicity. They can be white or non-white as those are racial categories.
··
Against
VirtualPoser5y ago
If the question was about Semitic people, the answer would be they are not. But being jewish is not a race, it is a religion. And that kinda disproves the "chosen people". How can yo be chosen if your religion is not race-bound?
··
Mixed
Shadow2224y ago
Judaism started in the Middle East, not in Europe, so in ancient times, historically jews were most certainly not white. That said, Judaism is a religion, not a race of people. Most of the 6 million Jews exterminated by the Nazi party in Germany, Poland, and surrounding countries were white. Anyone can be Jewish, I can, you can, and everyone you meet can. It’s a religion, and anyone can join it, just like any other religion. There are Black, White, Latino, Asian, and multi-racial Jews. To say that Jews are a race of people is just ignorant. If you were a Jew, living in the Middle East 2000 years ago, and your twin brother lived next door, but was an atheist, would you consider him of a different race because of his religious beliefs? Of course not, that’s just silly.
··
Mixed
keek214y ago
Most people here seem to be talking about the religion, however there is also a race of people who originate from Judea who are white. So the question is somewhat vague.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!