Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
6 comments
Against
Lucy_P5y ago
**When someone doesn't have God, they are fine. They do not need God to survive.**
- Humankind is not reliant on any beliefs to survive. Beliefs, although influential, do not guarantee or condemn our lives.
- Atheists, who do not believe in any God, are fine. They have not got a God, and are in the same position really as the people who do believe in God.
- My point is, man does not need God because, when someone doesn’t have God, they are completely fine.
··
Against
mlind215y ago
**Humankind does not *need* God. Believers *want* God.**
* Humankind does not rely on God to survive; we rely on things like each other, science, physical resources, nature, etc. To some, this is the work of God, but they *want* God to be real in order to fulfill their beliefs. I definitely don’t say this in a condescending way, just as general statement.
* Believers *want* God to be real, and in that sense they *need* God to bring comfort, guidance, and purpose in their lives, but humankind does not need God overall in order to survive as we have done for thousands of years.
··
Mixed
eleanorburleigh5y ago
**I think that man probably needed the idea of God to develop the social and moral communities we have today.**
- When I think of man 'needing' God, I'm thinking of God/religion as a human-made construct. It's something that appeals to our innate need for belonging and for meaning. In this sense, religion is something that provided humans with [a social and moral framework for existence] (https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20141219-will-religion-ever-disappear).
- The longevity of religions like Christianity shows the success of their provision of such frameworks. Seeing belief in God as something that plays [a vital role in societal evolution] (https://www.patheos.com/blogs/scienceonreligion/2013/05/why-the-templeton-foundation-is-a-darn-good-thing/) also accounts for [its popularity] (https://www.pewforum.org/2015/04/23/live-event-the-future-of-world-religions/) in parts of the world that are less economically or socially secure.
- But I think that in the [modern-day West] (https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190801-tomorrows-gods-what-is-the-future-of-religion), a lot of the values that arise from religious belief - like justice and compassion for others - have become central to secular society. [Religious practice is declining] (https://blog.oup.com/2020/12/why-is-religion-suddenly-declining/), but it is still prominent, and it may well never entirely go away. However, I would say that the human need for it has.
- Two interesting books on this topic are:
1. ['Dominion' by Tom Holland] (https://books.google.co.uk/books/about/Dominion.html?id=CWyGDwAAQBAJ&redir_esc=y) - where he argues, as a non-believer, that Christianity is "the most influential framework for making sense of human existence that has ever existed."
2. ['Why We Need Religion' by Stephen Asma] (https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/Why_We_Need_Religion/dIJZDwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=0) - he talks about the ways that religious belief functions as a "management system for our emotional lives."
··
For
JenReneeGilley5y ago
**TL;DR -- Humans need some kind of "god" to function on a mental/emotional level. Whether that be a diety, person, or object, we all worship *something*.**
First of all, it ought to be "humankind needs God," let's avoid the sexist terms here, please.
I think humans need *some kind* of god in order to feel intrinsically good about life. Whether that be the Christian God, any other diety, or even just a regular person or object, we all kind of worship *something*.
Have a favorite text, news source, or (insert media here) that is your go-to for information, entertainment, or even morals and values? There's your bible.
Have certain tasks you need to perform daily, or before you do bigger tasks, that you simply *must* do in order to get the bigger task done? There are your rituals.
Have a person whose every word you hang on, who you believe in with your whole heart and mind, like a mentor, celebrity, or best friend? Do you give them gifts often to show your love and/or impress them? Do you go to them with your problems and ask for their help or advice? There's your god.
Gods can even be items that we can't live without. For many of us, these are our phones. We trust them to a fault to organize our lives, act as sources of information, and function as communication devices, among many other things. For me, if I wasn't a Christian, it would be my video game consoles, because I can't get through a tough time without them.
Humans naturally fixate on things. It's an evolutionary trait that helps us make sense of the world around us, and even helps us to function in our daily lives. One researcher even [compares our "religion instinct" to drug use/addiction](https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190529-do-humans-have-a-religion-instinct) (which, to some, drugs are *their* gods).
Think about the people and things in your life. Who or what do you "worship" or fixate on? I'd love to hear your answers!
··
Commentary
vincenthan20095y ago
To properly address this opinion, it is necessary to have a clearer definition on what it means to "need" and the nature of "God". By need, does it mean a physical or physiological necessity, or a spiritual and inward desire? By God, does it refer to the specific, anthropomorphic creator God in Abrahamic religions, or a non-specfied, deistic supreme being? A vague opinion like this demands specification.
··
Against
user09875y ago
Nobody can even demonstrate that God exists, and thus, it cannot be demonstrated that God is needed.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!