Opinion
Lab

See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.

Gender

AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Log in to see how you compare
Share to
https://www.parlia.com/o/mulan-is-best-disney-film

11 comments

For
Hatty5y ago
**TL;DR - Mulan is the best Disney film as it actively challenges gender roles and preferences. Many Disney films prize the masculinity of a man above femininity of a woman. However, Mulan shows the benefits of a man and a woman performing both masculine and feminine activities, and does not prize one form over the other. There is also a blur of gender roles from the idea that men and women can be both masculine and feminine, with neither taking precedence over the other.** Often in Disney films, it is the brute strength tied to masculinity and a man that saves the day. This is noted by the many films in which the masculine man saves the feminine woman through the man embodying masculinity as femininity, tied to a woman, is not enough. Whilst other more recent films do have strong female characters such as Moana, there is still this idea that Moana would not have been able to complete her journey without the help and brute strength/masculinity of Maui, something which she is unable to embody herself. However, Mulan shows that girls and boys (as it is aimed at children) can both be masculine and can have brute strength and physical dominance if they wish, but they can also incorporate femininity and both are just as valid as each other. In the scene in which Mulan and the army are trying to gain entry into the palace, the sheer masculine brute strength in trying to knock down the door does not work, and instead using femininity and what is considered feminine in terms of dress helps them climb the pillars and defeat the guards. However, Mulan also uses typically masculine fighting skills in order to defeat the enemy. This promoting the idea that masculinity and femininity isn't tied to a man or woman but all genders can incorporate attributes seen as masculine and feminine. This is also shown through the song 'Reflection'. In this song there is a particularly powerful image in which Mulan has half a neutral, half hyper-feminized, whilst also being partially covered by writing. The whole point of this song – and the underlying message of the movie – is that “boy” and “girl” are roles you put on, and not something innate to any one person. Due to the challenging of these gender roles, I believe Mulan is the best Disney film. It is the film that is most beneficial for children in the exploration of gender and shows that both masculine and feminine traits can be equally as important and useful as each other. References: https://thepopcornscoop.wordpress.com/2012/12/29/why-mulan-is-the-greatest-movie-disney-ever-made/ https://www.hercampus.com/school/kutztown/10-reasons-why-mulan-best-disney-movie https://www.shondaland.com/live/a21073307/disney-mulan-queerness/ https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/culture/story/mulan-helped-accept-sexuality-gender-55920902
··
Sorry, but I vote for Hercules (1997) all the way!
··
Turi5y ago
🧞‍♀️ **Aladdin**🧞‍♂️ Racial stereotypes. Gender stereotypes. Some proto-oedipal stuff. And STILL hands-down the greatest Disney movie of all time.
··
Maria935y ago
Aladdin is also my favourite Disney movie. It's so different from the other movies and such great music too!
··
Mulan is indeed the best Disney movie with so many memorable and funny characters. I think that this movie has a fine balance between being funny and touching at the same time.
··
msiacotos5y ago
**tldr: mulan is good because each musical number is so good and memorable, and the music is used to enhance the meta drama of the film** also the dramatic shift in the second act after "Girl Worth Fighting For" when they see the ravaged village (aka the realities of war) and the movie stops being a musical and starts being a war movie. Some have cited this movie for why Mulan is bad (not enough songs) but I think this meta text makes the story better. Songs in musicals are supposed to show us how extremely the characters are feeling their emotions. But in musicals those emotions take on song form in a kind of fantasy setting. The film takes a song that is naive, a group of soldiers who think that war is about getting the girl, and has it cut off as soon as they come across the village. This should transition into another song about how terrible war is and how tragic it is that Shang lost his father. Instead the movie takes the audience out of the musical fantasy and into a war film. To me, the musical elements are fantastic, but when combined with the total absence of them halfway through the movie, they really shine.
··
For
catrinw5y ago
Mulan has always been my favourite. She is strong, independent and smart. Also, Mulan has a great storyline too. The movie also has a really good soundtrack. Mulan is the best Disney protagonist as well as the best Disney film.
··
Against
**TL;DR: *The Lion King* is Disney's best film because it has superior characters when compared to *Mulan* whilst also providing an amazing plotline and great music.** *The Lion King* trumps *Mulan* as the best Disney film any-day! *The Lion King* has great musical numbers (Hakuna Matata, Can you Feel the Love Tonight, Be Prepared) and deep moral messages (Circle of Life, 'Never run from your past'). The story conveys strong messages about family and I argue that this is what gives Simba his strength as an adult, allowing the film to avoid an unintentional focus on masculine strength and assuming that this is what will save the day. Much like *Mulan*, the story has unique and more meaningful qualities which are sometimes absent in other Disney films. What makes *The Lion King* the superior film in my opinion is its characters. In a direct comparison between these two films, it is clear that *The Lion King* has more interesting and recognisable characters than *Mulan*. Timon and Pumbaa as a duo outnumber Mushu in comedic terms as well as creating some brilliant musical numbers. Scar is also one of Disney's most famous, greatest villains - I'm not sure the same can be said for Shan-Yu in *Mulan*?
··
msiacotos5y ago
I love Lion King, but the energy kind of starts to fall off after Nala finds Simba? Like the drama kind of falls apart. I think that Mulan has a more solid second half. (though I do concede Scar is a much better villain than whats his face from Mulan because Simba actually knows Scar which creates more tension, and Be Prepared is one of the best villain songs of all time when Mulan's villain didn't get one at all)
··
Against
**TLDR: Whilst Mulan is a great film, Inside Out is such an important film for children to see, as it can help them to understand their emotions, which in turn has far reaching positive implications for their life, such as relationship building and confidence.** So much of our adult lives can be linked to our childhood. Our attachment styles are formed during our early years, and often it is during childhood that we learn how we should consider our emotions (this can be positively or negatively). A film like Inside Out, made for children to help them navigate this learning experience, is such an important teaching tool, and provides symbolism they can apply to their emotions. Inside Out teaches us that our emotions are not something to be feared or avoided. Each one plays a vital role in how we navigate the world, and we should choose to embrace them. As someone with anxiety, this movie spoke to me in a way that no other Disney film has. It has taken a long time to learn not to just try not think about being anxious, and instead to consider it a moment, perhaps understand where it has come from and then move on. A lot of how I deal with my emotions right now is linked to how I was taught, or at least how I thought I was supposed to deal with emotions as a child. A film like Inside Out would have done wonders for understanding why I was feeling a certain way, and to learn that it is a very human thing, not something to be fixed.
··
Against
rabidfox4y ago
Emperors new groove is best
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!