Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
18 comments
For
SFRALEY335y ago
When you get home after a long and tough day after work who is the first one to greet you? Your dog! Cats are very independent creatures that can get along fine without their person. But your dog? No way. Some get separation anxiety when you leave the house, crying for hours on end. Who else is going to give you that much love and devotion? If you come home from committing a terrible crime, your dog doesn’t care. They are just as happy to see you. They are truly man's or woman's best friend.
Dogs are also easier to train than dogs. You can play with them in the backyard, take them for walks and hikes. Some cats can do this too, but not many. Cats are not easy to train as they are not eager to please like dogs are. Dogs are able to accompany their humans when they go hunting. Fetching birds and flushing other critters out of the bushes for their person. They are able to do so many more things with you than cats are.
Dogs are pack animals and are always looking to their humans to take the lead. Some want to cuddle and know that you are there. When you are upset most dogs want to make you feel better. By licking your face, or nudging you, or by just getting your attention off of what's making you sad.
··
MakenaLikewise5y ago
My feline friend left a trail of excrement on my windowsill this morning...might be time to hang up a new cat-sized rug on my wall and go puppy shopping
··
JenReneeGilley5y ago
Dogs eat their own poop and then lick you.
I rest my case.
··
LeeAnn5y ago
OMG! You're right. I forgot about that.
Oh well...
··
SFRALEY335y ago
Cats bring dead creatures inside your home, that may carry various forms of disease and other little bugs on them.
Not all dogs eat their own poop. Generally, there is a reason they are doing it like they are missing a particular nutrient from their diet and are trying to get it by eating poop.
··
JenReneeGilley5y ago
Not if you keep your cat strictly indoors, which is safer for them anyway. And if a mouse happens to get in your house, better to let the cat kill it before it spreads its little disease-pellets everywhere. There's a very beneficial aspect to having an apex predator in your home.
Also, dogs have been known to do the same thing. I had a dog once that periodically brought me dead rabbits... and *always* had the head partially chewed off.
And, good point about the nutrient thing.
··
LeeAnn5y ago
Hi Makena.
Oh, no! Did your cat really do that?
If so, there could be a host of reasons why. You don't necessarily have to go looking for a dog - not that there is anything wrong with having a dog. It's just that you already have your cat.
Maybe your cat is trying to get your attention - especially if this is the first time (s)he has done this.
··
johndoe111135y ago
My cat has separation anxiety and loves me far more than any dog has
··
dogs2y ago
cool
··
For
msiacotos5y ago
Some dogs have wiggles, and I like that. They are also soft and many like to be pet. The cats I have come across don't like to be pet. I like taking care of a dog because they engage with me back and cats don't tend to do that.
Though I understand why some people like cats, I will always prefer a dog.
··
JenReneeGilley5y ago
Dude, my cats won't let me sit down *five minutes* before climbing into my lap and demanding cuddles and petting. They also engage with me by wrestling with my arm, playing fetch (yes, one of my younger cats actually does this!), and playing chase around the house. I love it when my boy attacks my ankles and then runs, daring me to come get revenge.
It depends on an individual cat's personality. But it also depends on their human understanding cat language and how to get these majestic, proud, stand-offish creatures to engage.
Dogs love anyone without reason. But you have to *earn* a cat's love, and damn it, I respect that.
··
LeeAnn5y ago
Yes, Jen. It's the same with me.
I have one cat and she isn't as anti-social as I hear cats are made out to be.
I'll admit that she has a moments when she prefers her solitude and just wants to be left alone. But she also likes her cuddles, playtime, petting and being the center of attention.
Also, you are so right when you say that the way a cat behaves is dependent on the cat per se. Each cat has his/her own personality depending on the cat and the environment they grow up in - all of these things are influencers for cat (or any other animal) behavior.
Here, I would also like to add that all animals have their own personality and not just cats.
And while I suppose there will inevitably be this cats versus dogs debate going on, I think we should remember to appreciate both of these wonderful animals and their individual qualities. That is to say, no one is better than the other.
··
Against
RB5y ago
If you ever wanted to see an animal be visibly embarrassed, a cat is the creature for you. The reputation is of a graceful; elegant, intelligent creature- king of the jungle and suburbia both.
The reputation seems to hang heavily over the head of many a moggy. When a cat fails to gracefully leap onto the sofa; or to elegantly climb down from the windowsill and- worst of all- is outsmarted by a mouse, there is a palpable air of embarrassment.
You cannot watch a dog stand for several hours over a particular hole in the garden waiting for mice. You cannot watch the dog fail to catch the mouse when it exits the hole. You cannot watch the dog try to style out failing to catch the mouse by pretending that it was just walking in the other direction anyway, and that the mouse was incidental.
By far, the greatest advantage of having a cat is the chance to watch something so naturally independently make a tremendous hash of it. Both entertaining and relatable.
··
Commentary
LeeAnn5y ago
**TL;DR - Ask yourself, why does it (always) have to be dogs versus cats?**
Well, according to theguardian.com there is a grain of truth in the cat versus dog question and this division can be dated back as far as around 43 million years ago. Both of these somewhat ‘domesticated’ animals share a common ancestry with animals such as badgers, seals, sea-lions, hyaenas, meerkats, weasels, skunks, bears, etc.
Moreover, while they do share various similarities and features, apparently the main feature that is shared among them is that of their teeth. It is blade-like carnassial teeth – their fourth upper premolar and first lower molar – which bite together to shear through food.
Additionally, they also belong to the Carnivora (order) which is split into two well-defined groups, namely, feliformia and caniformia.
The feliformia are largely cat-like and tend to be more specialised meat-eaters, have shorter faces and retractable claws and many of them ambush and pounce their predators (with animals like the cheetah being a notable exception, running and chasing after their prey).
While the caniformia are largely dog-like consisting of the usual wolves, jackals, hyaenas etc. Other animals that make up this diverse groups of caniformia include skunks, weasels, otters, racoons, etc., as well as, marine carnivoran such as seals and 'sea dogs'.
So as you can see, it doesn’t necessarily have to be dogs versus cats, especially since they are family in a way - albeit distantly related.
Cats vs dogs: in terms of evolution, are we barking up the wrong tree?
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/jul/26/cats-vs-dogs-in-terms-of-evolution-are-we-barking-up-the-wrong-tree [accessed January 26, 2021].
··
Against
Meg_Stalham5y ago
Although dogs can be lovely, companionable friends, there are many ways in which cats are better.
First of all, many dog lovers say that dogs are more friendly and extroverted around humans, which is true, as dogs are generally more excitable. However sometimes it’s nice to have a pet who is more relaxed, who isn’t constantly barking for attention or whenever something moves outside the window.
Because of this calmness and lack of need for constant fuss, people often assume that cats do not care about their humans. Yet this is not necessarily true: when they feel like it, a cat can curl up on your lap for hours or softly mew when it wants to be stroked (instead of an ear-splitting bark for attention), and this selective need for attention can give both cat and human valuable time to get on with other things.
Also, on arrival home from work, a cat would quietly wander up to you and rub against your ankles lovingly as a greeting, instead of bounding up to the front door, jumping up over-excitedly and swinging its head back when you try and pat it. Cats certainly show affection just as much as dogs, however in a much more relaxed manner, which often gets confused for disinterest.
Cats are also much more low-maintenance, as they effectively take care of themselves (e.g. grooming, exercise, etc). While it’s true that vet bills aren’t going to be any cheaper than a dogs would be, the cat owner will definitely save money in terms of trips to the groomers, and dog-sitters, because cats don’t generally need these expenses.
For example if you went on a trip for a few days, you would need to book a sitter for the dog, while a cat would be quite content with the house to itself for a bit- all it would need is it’s litter tray and a big bowl of food. Dogs are more demanding in this sense, needing play time and walks twice a day, not to mention the chaotic excitement they burst into if you even mention the word ‘walk’.
Dogs are lovely creatures and I love them, but cats can give you just as much affection and company whilst being very low-maintenance at the same time.
··
JuliaBath5y ago
Hear, hear! Completey agree with you.
··
For
Susyq55y ago
I have selected "For" because the sociability afforded by dog ownership is such a positive benefit.
For those living alone the enforced walk in all sorts of weather brings more that physical exercise. Often the chats exchanged with other dog walkers are the only social exchanges of the day.
As a dedicated dog lover, even points presented by others as disadvantages are enjoyed by me.
··
Against
4evrgreeny1y ago
While I love dogs, I prefer cats.
Cats are cleaner than dogs, spending 30-50% of their day just grooming themselves. Unlike dogs that will happily stay gross and smelly if allowed to.
Cats smell better than dogs, due to how often cats groom themselves, they don't really have much of any smell to them. Dogs however have a natural smell that can't really be gotten rid of easily, or gotten rid of without risking the dog's skin health through over bathing.
Cats also tend to be much less intense when it comes to wanting affection, while dogs tend to get all jumpy, jumping on you, barking, running around and getting all up in your face. Cats frequently spend time with their person by simply wanting to spend time in the same room as, or nearby their person.
And when cats do become more demanding of attention, they aren't as loud or as in your face about it.
I just think cats are better. Still love dogs tho.
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!