Opinion
Lab
Lab
See how this opinion breaks down by gender, political spectrum and generation — and who shares your view.
Gender
AGREEDISAGREE
Male
Female
Non-binary
21 comments
For
freyaehope5y ago
**TL;DR: White people wearing dreadlocks is a form of cultural appropriation**
Hair is important. It has come to mean a lot more culturally than just a protein filament that grows out of our heads. We use our hair to express and beautify ourselves, but also to engage with our own culture: certain hairstyles are often associated with specific festivals, religious rituals, and even resistance movements. Hair is also a part of race, and different hair colours, textures, and styles have historically garnered more praise or stigma than others.
Dreadlocks [do not belong to a single culture](https://www.esquire.com/uk/style/grooming/a34465402/history-of-dreadlocks/). This hairstyle, which involves the matting of hair into locks, is found throughout history, geography, and culture. In Egypt, archaeologists have found [mummies with dreadlocks](https://medium.com/equality-includes-you/the-cultural-history-of-dreadlocks-9dd40c8e5ac5) still attached to their skulls. The first reference to dreadlocks in writing occurs around 1500BC in the Vedic scriptures, holy Hindu texts. The Hindu god Shiva is depicted with dreadlocks, which he used to catch [the goddess Ganga](https://www.learnreligions.com/ganga-goddess-of-the-holy-river-1770295) (who became the river Ganges) when she fell to Earth. Religious figures in many cultures wear (or wore) their hair in dreadlocks to symbolise a rejection of the material world: such as sadhus in India, priests of Akomfo in Ghana, and Aztec priests in Mexico. In many parts of Africa, dreadlocks hairstyles were instead reserved primarily for warriors, as a symbol of their strength.
Some historians believe that [some ancient Europeans wore their hair in dreadlocks](https://books.google.co.uk/books?hl=en&lr=&id=ZakDEAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=dreadlocks+celts&ots=j8JLNgJHNU&sig=5STY3OVYpoBmwFm5AOX5NSMUXEA&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=dreadlocks%20celts&f=false), with reference to certain parts of Greece and the Vikings, but to a lesser extent than the rest of the world.
In the 20th Century, dreadlocks attained new meaning with the formation of the [Rastafari movement](https://rawremediesllc.com/history-dreadlocks-rasta-movement/) by Haile Selassie and Marcus Garvey. This religion evolved as a form of Pan-Africanism, preaching black empowerment and unity and reinterpreting the Bible through a contemporary lens of racial oppression. They wore dreadlocks to symbolise Jesus as ‘the Lion of Judah’ (comparing their dreads to a lion’s mane), and also as a way to honour and emphasise their African heritage. The Rastafarian singer/songwriter Bob Marley blasted Rastafarianism into mainstream culture in the 1970s, and accordingly, dreadlocks became a very fashionable hairstyle. Dreadlocks are now more associated with Rastafarianism than any other culture, and therefore have also become a symbol of black resistance against oppression.
Dreadlocks have become inherently tied to ideas of race and resistance. Many argue that white people should not wear their hair in dreadlocks, because it is a form of cultural appropriation. Cultural appropriation is [“when a tradition, such as clothing or a hairstyle, is taken from a culture and used in a different way”](https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/48868704). The meaning or significance is discarded, which disrespects the culture in question. Cultural appropriation is usually enacted by a dominant culture over a historically colonised culture, which creates an unequal power relationship: cultural appropriation can be seen as a form of [neocolonialism](https://www.dukechronicle.com/article/2019/11/cultural-appropriation-as-neo-imperialism-asian-american). As historically white cultures have not incorporated dreadlocks (or at least not to the same extent as the majority non-white cultures that feature dreadlocks), white people adopt this hairstyle from cultures outside of their own. Most white people with dreadlocks wear them for aesthetic or anti-establishment rather than religious or cultural reasons, and therefore ignore or de-centre the long and complex race-centred history of dreadlocks. [Kyle Ring](https://www.esquire.com/uk/style/grooming/a34465402/history-of-dreadlocks/)succinctly explains that despite white protestations that ancient white cultures _might_ have had dreadlocks, “the modern-day wearing of dreadlocks by white people is unconnected to their own history and instead inspired by ours”.
What’s more, black people are routinely discriminated against in [education and the workplace](https://daily.jstor.org/how-natural-black-hair-at-work-became-a-civil-rights-issue/) because of their hair texture and hairstyles. The Nigerian writer [Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tz8MHG-IIYM&ab_channel=DetKgl.BibliotekDetKgl.Bibliotek) boldly proclaims that “hair is political”. She argues that due to the negative assumptions attached to natural black hair, “If Michelle Obama had dreadlocks or an Afro or cornrows…Barack Obama would not have won”. Meanwhile, white celebrities such as [Justin Bieber](https://www.esquire.com/style/grooming/a36519590/justin-bieber-new-hair-buzzcut-shaved-dreadlocks/) are beginning to receive some backlash for the ‘cultural insensitivity’ of wearing dreadlocks, but still receive much praise and defence for this fashion statement. This signifies that it is not only culturally ignorant for white people to wear dreadlocks, but also harmful to the progression of an equal society.
··
Turi5y ago
So well expressed...! 🙏
··
stealthbeast5y ago
I can't believe how much tunnel vision people can get.
First of all, we can drop the history lesson. It's irrelevant. The actual reason dreadlocks came to exist is because some hair just naturally binds in a way highly conducive to dreadlocks. That's why dreadlocks have been developed independently across so many different cultures around the world. Dreadlocks, as a generic concept, don't "belong" to anyone.
Dreadlocks are just what happens to this nappy, longassed rats nest I call my hair if I don't brush it INCESSENTLY all day. I struggle tremendously with ADLs so my long flowing bangs are regularly becoming dreadlocks with no input from me, and if I outright skip entire days of brushing, this phenomenon spreads to the rest of my head (though it clumps in the back). It then can take hours of brushing to correct this issue. I have to carry a brush like you have to carry a phone; it's just the way my hair binds together over time. It's not like I WANT dreadlocks... they just sort of happen to me.
But what if I did want dreadlocks? I mean, it would be MUCH easier and more consistent to manage, and I have the perfect hair for it, which is super rare in white people (I guess it's my puerto rican background? Not sure). Why shouldn't I celebrate my hair? Why shouldn't I feel free to get dreadlocks? SO many people have had the reaction of seeing my hair and instantly going, "WOW! Have you ever considered getting dreadlocks?" It's always either dreadlocks or braids getting recommended to me... and it makes sense. After all, it's conducive to the hair type I was born with. There's really not much else I can even do with this hair at this length. My options are limited and my hair is SUPER IN THE WAY. You think DREADLOCKS are cultural appropriation? I've seriously considered learning to wrap my hair in a turban. I'm desperate for ways to manage this fucking hair.
Needless to say, I reject the notion that I would somehow be racist by letting my hair be the way it naturally is.
Edit:
Actually, I'll get cheeky: You accusing someone of being racist, for having dreadlocks, for no other reason than that they're white, is kind of racist.
··
Turi5y ago
I'm neutral on this because I find it hard to work out how offensive this might be.
I'm white but Jewish, and so constantly translate things back into 'Jewish' - an emotional register I can access.
I would not be offended if non-Jews starting wearing kippas as fashion accessories.
I think I'd be way more exercised if non-Jews starting growing out sidelocks, because they were such clearly identifying signs of Judaism across the East where Jews were targets of relentless persection.
And I'd be histrionic if non-Jews started wearing yellow stars on their clothes for fashion.
I can't quite see where dreadlocks sit on that scale.
··
rabidfox4y ago
this doesn't make sense black people are made fun of for their hair so now they own that hair and no one else can use it? It belongs to lots of cultures germanic, nordic and celts all did it for personal hygiene. The British invented sewers so i guess everyone else should go back to throwing it out the window. Every culture takes things from other cultures.
··
Against
Acies5y ago
If white people shouldn't wear dreadlocks, black people shouldn't dye their hair blonde.
It's an absurd excuse to be racist against white people.
··
stealthbeast5y ago
I see it as a well-intended, but radical overextension of the concept of cultural appropriation.
··
Linda5y ago
It's absurd to be racist to anyone.
I don't think dreadlocks are inherently black, all hair can be dreadlocked.
··
marktaha10mo ago
One -I think they look ridiculous. Two -I think that other people's hairstyles are none of my business.
··
For
Sg915y ago
I agree on the ground that no one should wear dreadlocks.
They're dirty and ugly.
··
plantfood5y ago
See, this is actually a contributing point as to why white people should not have dreadlocks.
Coily hair can naturally form locs and be unassembled FAR more easily than someone without textured hair trying to achieve the same 'dread.' The reason that a number of people have the impression that dreads are "dirty" is because people without that natural curl pattern in their hair literally just knot the strands, which makes the hair completely unmanageable (can't brush it/wash it/style it/etc.).
Unpack why you think they're ugly by yourself though, that just seems sus and bordering racist to me 👀
··
Sg915y ago
I think you need to unpack why you think not liking a certain hairstyle is borderline racist.
I don't care what colour the person wearing the dreads is, they still look dirty and daft.
··
Linda4y ago
Actually wearing dreadlocks is holistic, clean and more environmentally friendly than trips to the hair salon, or hair products full of pollutants, regardless of what you consider yourself to be!
··
For
francesca246015y ago
**White people wearing dreadlocks is cultural appropriation**
- Dreadlocks have huge cultural and spiritual history
- People of colour frequently face racist microaggressions and oppression because of their hair and hair styles such as dreadlocks whereas when white people wear them they do not face the same microaggressions and are often praised for them
- Dreadlocks can be much harder to implement, maintain and wear on white people with finer, straight hair and can in fact be very damaging to the hair
··
Against
angel23115y ago
As a black person myself, I have no problem with people of other races wearing predominantly black hairstyles unless you're being disrespectful. That's all I really have to say on this.
··
For
Bobsaget15y ago
White people should stop dressing like black people and acting like them, all together. It's embarrassing.
··
Against
PhageLord5y ago
It is possible to participate in another culture as a form of appreciation--recognizing that it is being borrowed--and without attempting to claim it for one's own culture.
··
Against
Jezzaftw5y ago
Real overstrech for cultural appropriation.
Nobody wants to play a game where we divide ourselves more by saying what people can wear and what they cant wear because of their skin colour.
For example if I said people who arent white shouldnt be allowed to wear suits because those were invented by a british gentlemen everyone would scream racism, this opinion is just a double standard imo.
··
Against
LokiTheJedi4y ago
I don’t think white people should wear dreadlocks, not because I think it’s cultural appropriation, but because I have yet to see a white person who looks good in them.
··
Commentary
Battlehammer3y ago
Dreadlocks did not originate in black society. They originated in place like Minoan civilization in Ancient Greece and later in ancient Egypt. They were also used in the Nordic regions of the Vikings, so nice tey
··
Sign up or log in to post a comment.
Are we missing an argument?
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!
Make the case or invite a friend to comment!