argument top image

Are humans responsible for climate change? Show more Show less
Back to question

Climate change isn't just global warming, it's also a change in regional or global weather patterns. There are many other factors though that cause these world wide changes. People have been questioning whether humans are at fault for climate change or if the fears surrounding it are real at all.

No, humans are not responsible for climate change Show more Show less

Humans aren't responsible for climate change because its a natural occurring process. The planet has gone through many different climate changes over the millions of years its existed.
< (2 of 3) Next position >

Climate change is a naturally occurring process that happens through history

This isn't the first time earth has experienced a global climate change and it won't be the last time. Climate change is a process that people seem to forget doesn't have to take millions of years but can happen much faster, sometimes instantaneously. Humans are just along for the ride.

The Argument

Climate change is a process that occurs naturally throughout history. To blame it all on humans ignores the fact that nature cannot be controlled. While people have been trying to manipulate nature to their benefit, it doesn’t always work out. Whether through prayer or science, there's a reason it's referred to as a force of nature. As time goes on and peoples' knowledge of science continues to grow, so too does their understanding of how things happen. We understand why climate change is happening and how it happens. We don’t completely understand how to undo it though.[1] People continuously promote green energy and eco-friendly materials, but they’re all looking for instant fixes. They want the answers and solutions immediately. Fixes for climate change are not immediate. The Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) took almost 200,000 years to return to normal temperatures. The last ice age the planet had also took place 2.6 million years ago and even lasted till about only 11,700 years ago. It took more than 2.5 million years to return to normal temperatures.[2] This current climate change, while faster, is just another change the planet is going through, much like the PETM and the ice age. Humans are trying to counteract it, but you cannot stop nature, only work alongside it.

Counter arguments

Climate change isn't a recent happening, people have seen cases all throughout the planets history. The problem is with how fast it's progressing. Tens of thousands of years only taking hundreds of years for the same results. People are becoming afraid because while climate change is natural, what's happening is an irregularity. An irregularity that's happening because of outside intervention. The PETM might've happened a long time ago but looking at the time period shows the future humans are heading towards. The change in temperature, while only a few degrees to some, is in truth deadly. Humans can survive about 108 degree Fahrenheit temperatures, but schools close down when temperatures reach above 100 degrees.[3]. Just this year, California, Death Valley reached 130 degree Fahrenheit.[4] A few degrees might not seem like much but when these temperatures are the consequence, it doesn’t matter if historically the planet has come out of it naturally. It doesn’t matter if it’s natural or man made changes. The real question is will everyone survive it.

Proponents

Premises

[P1] While this is the first time humans are properly recording climate change there are records of it happening to the earth before humans populated it

Rejecting the premises

[RP1] If the temperature climbs to high it can start to become a deadly threat

References

  1. https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/why-climate-change-happening-and-what-are-causes-1?qt-news_science_products=0#qt-news_science_products
  2. https://www.livescience.com/40311-pleistocene-epoch.html
  3. https://fortune.com/2018/08/27/extreme-heat-closing-northeast-back-to-school/
  4. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/09/12/climate-change-why-heatwaves-are-more-deadly-as-nights-warm-faster.html
This page was last edited on Tuesday, 1 Dec 2020 at 10:33 UTC

Explore related arguments