argument top image

Did nationalism predate nation states? Show more Show less
Back to question

Today, we are used to both the nation-state and the idea of nationalism. However, it may be possible to have one without the other. Authors have written about nationalism for centuries, but the nation state as we know it has existed a relatively short amount of time. So, did nationalism predate the nation?

Yes, nationalism predated nation states. Show more Show less

There is strong evidence of behaviors akin to nationalism in societies that predate our modern idea of the "nation state."
(1 of 3) Next position >

Greek city states had a national identity

Greek city states rallied under a banner to defend their city against the Persian empire.

Context

City state: a city that with its surrounding territory forms an independent state.

The Argument

In Ancient Greece, there were over a thousand different city states [1], each with their own cultural identity. Athens was known for producing scientists, philosophers, and writers, whilst Sparta was famed for its prowess at warfare, and each city state had its own system of government, varying from rule by kings to democracy. However, despite their differences, these city states felt a common identity when fighting the non-Greek state of Persia, and the Greek victory was seen as a triumph for Greek culture and politics, even though what that meant specifically varied from city to city. [2] This suggests that nationalist identity has existed since before modern nation states, and that groups do not have to be culturally identical to feel a strong bond to one another.

Counter arguments

This sense of Ancient Greek nationalism is very loose and was formed only in the face of the threat of Persian conquest: before that, the cultural differences between many Greek city states had caused them to fight amongst themselves. Using this as a clear example of nationalism fails to recognise that it was not strongly developed, and only emerged at a point of crisis.

Proponents

Framing

This is a very specific argument drawing on the Greco-Persian Wars of 492 BCE to 449 BCE, suggesting that nationalism existed amongst these Greek city states when they were attacked by Persia.

Premises

1. Ancient Greek city states, despite their cultural differences, fought together against the Persians to protect Greek culture. 2. The city states were not unified as one nation state, suggesting that nationalism came before nation states.

Rejecting the premises

1. This nationalism only emerged when Greece was under threat from Persia, not necessarily beforehand. 2. City states had often fought amongst themselves.

References

  1. https://www.nationalgeographic.org/encyclopedia/greek-city-states/#:~:text=There%20grew%20to%20be%20over,%C3%81rgos%2C%20Er%C3%A9tria%2C%20and%20Elis.
  2. https://www.britannica.com/event/Greco-Persian-Wars

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more ↑

Discuss

This page was last edited on Saturday, 27 Jun 2020 at 15:24 UTC

Explore related arguments