convo top image

Should Puerto Rico become a US state or independent?

Puerto Rico, one of five American territories, has limited power and rights under its territory categorization. Some mainland Americans argue Puerto Rico should become the 51st U.S. state. Activists in Puerto Rico go one step further—full independence.

Puerto Rico should become a US state

Puerto Rico has been a US territory for over 100 years. No US territory that has fit all statehood requirements and voted for a referendum has waited that long for statehood. It's time to abide by the wishes of the Puerto Rican people and give them statehood, which comes with increased federal benefits and the ability to vote.

The people of Puerto Rico have voted for it

Puerto Rico citizens have voted numerous times on statehood referendums. It’s time to give the majority what they desire.

Puerto Ricans are US citizens

Puerto Ricans have been US citizens for over 100 years, but haven’t been granted the full benefits that come with citizenship. Completing the statehood process would grant those benefits and silence constitutional detractors.

Puerto Ricans should have the ability to vote in Congress—and for President

Puerto Ricans are US citizens and have their own government, yet are unable to vote in Presidential elections and do not have a voting member of Congress. This leaves roughly 3.2 million people out of the voting process that America fought so hard to erect.

Puerto Rico would receive increased federal benefits

Puerto Rico has a number of inequities in federal programs like Medicaid and family tax credits and is ineligible for food stamps for disaster victims. Statehood would immediately help out the island, which has been ravaged by natural disasters.

Puerto Rico should be an independent country

Puerto Rico was seized by America after the Spanish-American War and has its own unique culture, heritage, and ingenious people separate from the US. Puerto Rico deserves to be given what it once had—autonomy and its own, localized government.

Public pressure for independence

A growing movement on the island has been pushing back against the traditional statehood route. Instead, they’ve been calling for something bigger—autonomy.

The US colonized Puerto Rico

The US has traditionally been opposed to colonialism by foreign nations. Yet, the US took Puerto Rico as a “prize” from the Spanish-American war.

America has a history of attempting to preserve democracy

Since World War II under President Truman, the US has attempted to promote free and open democracies abroad. That promotion shouldn’t stop now.

Puerto Rico would have a more localized government

Puerto Rico has a local government, but Puerto Rican laws can be overruled by the US government, and all laws have to be within US law. Puerto Rico deserves a more localized and democratic government.
Explore this question in a whole new way.
This page was last edited on Thursday, 29 Oct 2020 at 17:54 UTC