Mapping the world's opinions

argument top image

Should corporal punishment be allowed? Show more Show less

Corporal punishment - state sanctioned physical punishment - has been banned in 58 countries worldwide. However, some argue these bans deter violent crime. Should corporal punishment be allowed? Can it be an effective disciplinary tool? Or is it linked to skyrocketing crime rates?

No, corporal punishment is bad Show more Show less

Corporal punishment legitimises violence and causes long term psychological damage. It has no place in modern society.
(1 of 3 Positions) Next >

Corporal punishment offers no restitution

Part of the punitive process is to offer restitution to victims. This stage is absent in methods of corporal punishment.
< Previous (3 of 6 Arguments) Next >

Context

Restitution is an important part of the punitive process. Corporal punishment offers no form of restitution to the victim or the community that suffered.

The Argument

The most effective punishments have a restitutive aspect to them. The restitutive process is important to get the transgressor to acknowledge that their actions had a detrimental impact on the lives of others. Corporal punishment has no restitutive factor. It does nothing for the individual or the community wronged by the infraction or transgression. Unlike community service or fines, which offer some collective benefit, corporal punishment fails to compensate the victims affected.

Counter arguments

We do not have to make amends to a victim in order for a punishment to be effective. Many crimes are victimless crimes in the sense that there is no victim for the offender to offer restitution to. These offenders are still able to learn from their crimes and be rehabilitated. Therefore, restitution is not an essential component of the punitive process.

Framing

Premises

[P1] Restitution is an important part of the punitive process. [P2] There is no restitutive component in corporal punishment. [P3] Therefore, corporal punishment should not be permitted.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P1] Restitution is not an important part of the punitive process.

Proponents

Further Reading

References

    Explore related arguments

    This page was last edited on Wednesday, 5 Feb 2020 at 18:35 UTC