argument top image

Should corporal punishment be allowed? Show more Show less
Back to question

Corporal punishment - state sanctioned physical punishment - has been banned in 58 countries worldwide. However, some argue these bans deter violent crime. Should corporal punishment be allowed? Can it be an effective disciplinary tool? Or is it linked to skyrocketing crime rates?

No, corporal punishment is bad Show more Show less

Corporal punishment legitimises violence and causes long term psychological damage. It has no place in modern society.
< (2 of 3) Next position >

Corporal violence is never administered evenhandedly

A punishment must be immune from societal influences and be administered evenhandedly.
< (4 of 6) Next argument >

Context

A legal system can only be effective when the public trusts the system to administer punishment evenhandedly. Corporal punishment is not administered evenhandedly due to societal influences. Therefore, corporal punishment leads to reduced public trust in the legal system.

The Argument

Due to societal and cultural norms around gender, boys are always on the receiving end of harsher corporal punishments. If a punishment system cannot be administered evenly across all demographics, it should not be used. [1] If a punishment method is adopted that does not punish all offenders evenly, the public will lose trust in the legal system and the rules-based order is undermined.

Counter arguments

Corporal punishment is meted out evenly. A study in the US found that 67% of mothers and 68% of fathers slapped or spanked their children as a punishment and there was no apparent gender difference between boys and girls. [2]

Premises

[P1] A legal system can only be effective when the public trusts the system to administer punishments evenhandedly. [P2] Corporal punishment is not administered evenhandedly. [P3] Therefore, corporal punishment erodes public trust in the legal system. [P4] Therefore, corporal punishment should not be allowed.

Rejecting the premises

[Rejecting P2] Corporal punishment can be administered evenhandedly.

References

  1. https://soapboxie.com/social-issues/Should-corporal-punishment-in-schools-be-allowed-Arguments-for-and-against
  2. https://www.psychologytoday.com/au/blog/media-spotlight/201701/spare-the-rod-and-spoil-the-child

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more ↑

Discuss

This page was last edited on Wednesday, 5 Feb 2020 at 18:30 UTC

Explore related arguments