argument top image

What are the solutions to the Israel Palestine conflict? Show more Show less
Back to question

What started as intercommunal violence between Israelis and Arabs in the 1920s evolved over the course of the twentieth century into a full-blown civil war and open conflict. After much bloodshed and the dawn of a new century, what would a solution to the Israel-Palestine situation look like? Is peace even a possibility for one of the world's longest-running conflicts?

There is no solution to the Israel Palestine conflict Show more Show less

The political objectives of both sides, coupled with the current political climate, mean that no solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict is available.
< (5 of 5)

The US is not a viable peace broker for the Israel Palestine conflict

The US is one of the few nations capable of brokering peace but it is not willing to do so.
< (4 of 4)

Context

With its economic clout and vast coffers of foreign aid, the US will play an integral role in the peace process. Through diplomatic and economic pressure, it can bring both sides to the negotiating table and advance the peace process. However, in recent years, it has only made things worse.

The Argument

The US may be one of the only diplomatic forces on earth that could leverage its economic and financial clout to bring peace to the region. However, it has not sought to address the power imbalances and underlying conflicts playing out in the region. Instead of pressuring the Israeli government to end its occupation, it has sought to reassure it. It has also tried to reform Palestinian aspirations rather than work with both sides to find mutually agreeable terms. Pressuring the weaker party and supporting the stronger party is not the role of a mediator or peace broker. The void of a viable peace broker will mean neither side has an incentive to further negotiations.

Counter arguments

Proponents

Premises

[P1] The US is one of the few forces capable of brokering peace. [P2] The US is not behaving like a peace broker. [P3] Therefore, the conflict will not be resolved through US-led negotiations.

Rejecting the premises

References

Vote

Not sure yet? Read more ↑

Discuss

This page was last edited on Thursday, 17 Sep 2020 at 07:26 UTC

Explore related arguments